UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q76 · Reasoning
If P means 'greater than (>)'; Q means 'less than (<)'; R means 'not greater than (≯)'; S means 'not less than (≮)' and T means 'equal to (=)', then consider the following statements :
1. If 2x (S)3y and 3x(T)4z, then 9y(P) 8z.
2. If x (Q)2y and y(R)z, then x (R)z.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Both Statement 1 (which yields 9y ≤ 8z instead of 9y > 8z) and Statement 2 (which fails when x is chosen between y and 2y) are logically incorrect.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Decoding symbols gives P as >, Q as <, R as ≤ (not greater than), S as ≥ (not less than), and T as =.
- Statement 1 gives 2x ≥ 3y and 3x = 4z. Expressing x in terms of z gives x = 4z / 3.
- Substituting x into 2x ≥ 3y yields 2(4z / 3) ≥ 3y, which simplifies to 8z ≥ 9y or 9y ≤ 8z.
- Statement 1 claims 9y > 8z, which directly contradicts 9y ≤ 8z, making Statement 1 false.
- Statement 2 gives x < 2y and y ≤ z, asking if x ≤ z must hold true.
- Consider numerical values: let y = 5 and z = 5, which satisfies y ≤ z.
- Then 2y = 10. Choosing x = 7 satisfies x < 2y (7 < 10), but x ≤ z (7 ≤ 5) is false.
- Since x ≤ z does not hold universally, Statement 2 is false.
- Since both Statement 1 and Statement 2 have been mathematically proven false, option (c) cannot be correct.
- Statement 1 simplifies to 9y ≤ 8z, contradicting the claim 9y > 8z.
- Statement 2 fails using a counter-example where y = 5, z = 5, and x = 7.
- Since neither statement is correct, option (d) is the right answer.
Concept to know
- Symbol decoding step: First translate non-standard operation symbols into standard mathematical relations (>, <, ≤, ≥, =).
- Not greater than (≯) is mathematically equivalent to less than or equal to (≤).
- Not less than (≮) is mathematically equivalent to greater than or equal to (≥).
- Substitution method: Use exact equality relations to express one variable in terms of another and substitute into the inequality.
- Counter-example method: To disprove a universal logical assertion in inequalities, find a single set of real numbers that satisfies the given conditions but violates the conclusion.
Related facts for revision
- Coded Inequalities: Common CSAT problem type testing logical sign substitution and algebraic manipulation.
- Transitive Property: If a < b and b < c, then a < c; but multipliers like 2y disrupt transitivity unless constraints are strictly bounded.
- Edge Case Testing: When variable signs (positive, negative, zero) are unspecified, test boundary values.
- Sign Reversal Rule: Multiplying or dividing an inequality by a negative number reverses the direction of the inequality sign.
Mathematical logical reasoning, symbol conversion, and evaluating inequality expressions using substitution and counter-examples.
Trap: Misinterpreting 'not greater than' as strictly 'less than' instead of 'less than or equal to', or assuming transitivity holds when coefficient multipliers are involved.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.