EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q44 · Comprehension

Year2024
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ44
SubjectComprehension

By the time children reach class 8, the bulk of them tend to be in the age range of 13 years to 15 years. But in our country, about a quarter of all children in class 8 struggle with reading simple texts and more than half are still unable to do basic arithmetic operations like division. Every year about 25 million young boys and girls from elementary school move into the life that lies for them beyond compulsory schooling. They cannot enter the workforce at least in the organized sector till they are 18. For many families, these children are the first from their families ever to get this far in school. Parents and children expect that such 'graduates' from school will go on to high school and college. Hardly anyone wants to go back to agriculture. On the other hand, abilities in terms of academic competencies are far lower than they should be even based on curricular expectations of class 8.

Passage-2

We take it for granted now that science has a social responsibility. The idea would not have occurred to Newton or Galileo. They thought of science as an account of the world as it is, and the only responsibility that they acknowledged was to tell the truth. The idea that science is a social enterprise is modern, and it begins at the industrial revolution. We are surprised that we cannot trace a social sense further back, because we nurse the illusion that the industrial revolution ended a golden age.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the central idea of the above passage?

  1. aParents in general may not be of much help when children are on their way to becoming adults.
  2. bWhen children reach adolescence, involvement of parents in their lives is unnecessary.
  3. cModern-day nuclear families are not capable of bringing up children properly.
  4. dIn modern societies, adolescents tend to be stubborn, disobedient and careless.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) Parents in general may not be of much help when children are on their way to becoming adults.

The passage states that parents offer dogmatic solutions that adolescents do not trust, leading them to follow their own paths, implying parents may not be of much help during this transition.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Option (a)
  • The passage highlights that parental solutions during adolescence are often too dogmatic for youth to rely on.
  • Youth end up secretly following their own discovered paths, showing that parents in general may not be of much assistance during this phase.
✗ Option (b)
  • The claim that parental involvement is completely unnecessary is an extreme generalization not supported by the text.
  • The passage discusses the nature of conflict and dogmatic advice, not that parents should stop being involved entirely.
✗ Option (c)
  • The passage does not mention nuclear families or their capability to bring up children.
  • Introducing modern-day nuclear families as a concept is an out-of-scope extrapolation.
✗ Option (d)
  • The passage describes conflict as a natural outcome of adolescent independence and parental anxiety.
  • It does not label adolescents with judgmental traits such as stubborn, disobedient, or careless.

Concept to know

  • Central Idea Identification: Focus on the core premise of the author rather than secondary details or outside assumptions.
  • Eliminating Extreme Claims: Words like unnecessary or completely invalid usually indicate overly broad or unstated conclusions.
  • Avoiding Unstated Concepts: Ensure terms not present in the passage (such as nuclear families) are not inferred as main ideas.
  • Tonal Neutrality: Avoid choosing options that assign subjective moral judgments (like stubborn or careless) unless explicitly stated by the author.

Related facts for revision

  • Main Idea vs. Supporting Detail questions in CSAT reading comprehension.
  • Recognizing extreme qualifiers like always, never, completely, or unnecessary in options.
  • Distinguishing author perspective from implicit real-world biases.
  • Handling passages on social and behavioral sciences by relying strictly on given premises.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to extract the main conclusion of a behavioral passage without bringing in external assumptions or extreme views.

Trap: Options (b) or (d) can trap candidates who impose real-world stereotypes about adolescents or overinterpret parental conflict as total irrelevance.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.