UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q32 · Comprehension
"The history of science is the real history of mankind." In this striking epigram, a nineteenth-century writer links science with its background. Like most epigrams, its power lies in emphasizing by contrast an aspect of truth which may be easily overlooked. In this case, it is easy to overlook the relations between science and mankind, and to treat the former as some abstract third party, which can sometimes be praised for its beneficial influences, but frequently and conveniently blamed for the horrors of war. Science and mankind cannot be divorced from time to time at men's convenience. Yet we have seen that, in spite of countless opportunities of improvement, the opening years of the present period of civilization have been dominated by international conflict. Is this the inevitable result of the progress of science or does the fault lie elsewhere?
Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. The horrors of modern life are the inevitable result of the progress of science.
2. The aspect of truth likely to be overlooked is that science is what man has made it.
Which of the assumptions given above is/are correct?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Assumption 2 logically follows because the passage highlights that people overlook the connection between science and human creation, while Assumption 1 states as a fact what the author explicitly questions.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The author asks whether international conflict is the inevitable result of the progress of science or if the fault lies elsewhere.
- Since the author leaves this as an open question rather than asserting it, assuming it as a definitive fact contradicts the passage.
- Therefore, Assumption 1 is invalid.
- The passage notes that people tend to treat science as an abstract third party, overlooking its direct relation with mankind.
- This implies the overlooked aspect of truth is that science is created by human beings and reflects human choices.
- Therefore, Assumption 2 is a valid underlying premise.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must believe to be true for their main argument to hold.
- Use the Negation Test: If negating a statement causes the central logic of the passage to collapse, that statement is a necessary assumption.
- Distinguish carefully between explicit facts, open rhetorical questions, and valid implicit assumptions.
- Avoid options that treat an open question raised by the author as a settled conclusion.
- Ensure assumptions strictly stay within the logical boundaries of the text without bringing in outside real-world bias.
Related facts for revision
- Inference vs Assumption questions: Inferences are logical conclusions derived from premises, while assumptions are the missing premises themselves.
- Extreme words trap: Options using absolute language such as inevitable, always, or completely require strong explicit textual justification.
- Rhetorical Question Analysis: When an author asks a question at the end of a passage, it usually signals doubt rather than endorsement of the idea.
- Main Idea Identification: Identifying the core theme helps eliminate assumptions that go against the author's overall direction.
Evaluating implicit assumptions and distinguishing an author's skeptical inquiry from a settled assertion.
Trap: Candidates often select Assumption 1 because of real-world associations between science and modern warfare, ignoring that the author explicitly questions this link in the final sentence.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.