UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q23 · Comprehension
We take it for granted now that science has a social responsibility. The idea would not have occurred to Newton or Galileo. They thought of science as an account of the world as it is, and the only responsibility that they acknowledged was to tell the truth. The idea that science is a social enterprise is modern, and it begins at the industrial revolution. We are surprised that we cannot trace a social sense further back, because we nurse the illusion that the industrial revolution ended a golden age.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the thinking of the author about the science?
- aScience must value the commitment of the scientists.
- bScience is a product of civilized society and must be used for the promotion of scientific awareness in people.
- cIndustrial revolution was made possible by the advancements in science.
- dScience must pursue truth but be responsible for social welfare.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The author synthesizes the classical responsibility of science (telling the truth) with its modern role (having a social responsibility/enterprise for public welfare).
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage discusses the responsibility of science toward truth and society, not the evaluation or valuing of a scientist's personal commitment.
- This statement shifts focus to scientists' personal traits rather than the scope and function of science itself.
- The passage emphasizes that science has a social responsibility, but it nowhere mentions using science specifically to promote scientific awareness among the general public.
- This introduces an unsubstantiated detail not present in or implied by the passage text.
- The passage notes that the idea of science as a social enterprise begins at the industrial revolution, but it does not claim that scientific advancements made the industrial revolution possible.
- This option incorrectly infers a causal economic historical statement not asserted by the author.
- The author acknowledges that early scientists like Newton and Galileo rightly saw science's duty as seeking and telling the truth about the world.
- The author also highlights the modern understanding that science is a social enterprise with social responsibility, making option (d) the complete reflection of the author's perspective.
Concept to know
- Reading Comprehension author's perspective questions require synthesizing both traditional context and modern arguments presented in the text.
- Identify core contrasts: the passage contrasts Newton/Galileo's truth-seeking role of science with the post-Industrial Revolution social responsibility role.
- Distinguish between necessary implications grounded in the text and extraneous assumptions not stated by the author.
- Eliminate options that focus on narrow historical causes or unmentioned goals like public awareness campaign details.
- Choose the option that encompasses the dual themes of the passage rather than just a partial truth.
Related facts for revision
- Main idea and central theme identification techniques in short CSAT passages.
- Distinguishing authorial opinion from historical facts or characters mentioned in the passage.
- Handling premise-conclusion structures where classical views are expanded by modern views.
Ability to integrate two complementary ideas present in the text to identify the author's comprehensive viewpoint.
Trap: Option (b) and (c) use familiar concepts like scientific awareness and industrial revolution to create plausible-sounding but unsupported traps.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.