UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q66 · Data Sufficiency
A Question is given followed by two Statements I and II. Consider the Question and the Statements.
Question :
If the average marks in a class are 60, then what is the number of students in the class?
Statement-I :
The highest marks in the class are 70 and the lowest marks are 50.
Statement-II :
Exclusion of highest and lowest marks from the class does not change the average.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?
- aThe Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone
- bThe Question can be answered by using either Statement alone
- cThe Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
- dThe Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Combining both statements yields an algebraic identity that holds for any class size of 3 or more students, failing to uniquely determine the number of students.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I provides maximum mark 70 and minimum mark 50 but gives no information on the number of students.
- Statement II implies the sum of excluded extreme marks is twice the average, which leads to a redundant algebraic identity.
- Neither statement alone can independently determine the total number of students in the class.
- Neither statement alone provides a solvable equation with a unique value for student count N.
- Statement I leaves N completely open for any integer value of 3 or greater.
- Statement II is a mathematical property that automatically holds true whenever the average of the removed values equals the original class average.
- Combining both statements gives the sum of highest and lowest marks as 70 + 50 = 120.
- The updated average equation (60N - 120) / (N - 2) = 60 simplifies to 60N - 120 = 60N - 120, which is an identity valid for all N >= 3.
- Because any class size N = 3, 4, 5, ... satisfies both statements simultaneously, combining them still does not give a unique answer.
- Statement I specifies extreme values 70 and 50, but allows class size N to take any integer value greater than or equal to 3.
- Statement II states that excluding these values does not alter the average, which is mathematically trivial since (70 + 50) / 2 = 60.
- Even together, the statements produce a tautology rather than a unique linear equation for N, so the question cannot be answered.
Concept to know
- Average is defined as the sum of all observations divided by the total number of observations N.
- Removing observations whose average equals the original class mean leaves the overall mean unchanged for any sample size N greater than the count of removed items.
- In Data Sufficiency questions, a set of statements is sufficient only if it yields a single unique value for the variable being determined.
- An algebraic equation that simplifies to an identity like 0 = 0 offers zero new independent information about the variable N.
- To find sample size N from mean values, specific counts or non-symmetric subgroup sums are required.
Related facts for revision
- Weighted average formula where combined mean depends on subgroup sizes and subgroup averages.
- Data sufficiency traps involving linearly dependent equations or identities leading to infinitely many solutions.
- Effect of removing outliers or extreme values on measures of central tendency such as mean, median, and mode.
- Deviation method where the algebraic sum of deviations of all observations from their arithmetic mean is always zero.
Ability to spot algebraic identities in Data Sufficiency problems and avoid assuming sufficiency when equations simplify to tautologies.
Trap: Candidates often assume that having specific numbers like 70 and 50 combined with an average condition allows calculating the total student count N.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.