UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q34 · Comprehension
Only with long experience and opening of his wares on many a beach where his language is not spoken, will the merchant come to know the worth of what he carries, and what is parochial and what is universal in his choice. Such delicate goods as justice, love and honour, courtesy, and indeed all the things we care for, are valid everywhere but they are variously moulded and often differently handled, and sometimes nearly unrecognizable if you meet them in a foreign land, and the art of learning fundamental common values is perhaps the greatest gain of travel to those who wish to live at ease among their fellows.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Travel leads to an understanding of humans.
2. Travel helps those who wish to learn fundamental common values.
3. A person with long experience in travel can resolve differences amongst people.
Which of the assumptions given above are valid?
- a1 and 2 only
- b2 and 3 only
- c1 and 3 only
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Assumptions 1 and 2 logically follow from the passage's emphasis on travel facilitating the understanding of common human values, whereas resolving differences is an unstated extrapolation.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage indicates that travel allows one to observe how universal values like justice, love, and courtesy are variously moulded in different cultures.
- Recognizing universal versus parochial elements in human behavior inherently leads to a broader understanding of humans.
- Therefore, the assumption that travel leads to an understanding of humans is validly implied.
- The author explicitly states that the art of learning fundamental common values is the greatest gain of travel for those wishing to live at ease among fellows.
- This directly supports the premise that travel aids individuals seeking to learn shared human values.
- Hence, Assumption 2 is valid and fully backed by the text.
- The passage highlights personal learning, cultural adaptability, and living at ease among others.
- It makes no reference to mediator roles, conflict resolution, or resolving disputes between individuals.
- Assuming that experienced travelers can resolve differences among people goes beyond the text and is invalid.
Concept to know
- Assumption questions require identifying unstated premises that must be true for the passage's argument to hold valid.
- Valid assumptions must directly align with the core context and scope of the text without introducing far-fetched claims.
- Distinguish between personal adaptation or understanding and active intervention like resolving conflicts.
- Extreme or out-of-scope assertions should be systematically eliminated.
- Check if removing the assumption weakens or breaks the central logical thesis of the passage.
Related facts for revision
- Critical Reading: Distinguishing direct inferences from unstated underlying assumptions.
- Scope Verification: Rejecting options that introduce external concepts like dispute resolution.
- Tone Analysis: Identifying the author's primary focus on individual gain and social harmony through cultural exposure.
- Elimination Technique: Invalidating options containing unsupported action-oriented claims.
Identifying valid reading comprehension assumptions without falling for over-generalized or out-of-scope claims.
Trap: Option (d) or (b) traps candidates who assume that understanding common values automatically implies the ability to resolve interpersonal differences.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.