EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q59 · Data Sufficiency

Year2024
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ59
SubjectData Sufficiency

A Question is given followed by two Statements I and II. Consider the Question and the Statements.
Question :
What are the values of m and n, where m and n are natural numbers?
Statement-I :
m + n > mn and m > n.
Statement-II :
The product of m and n is 24.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?

  1. aThe Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone
  2. bThe Question can be answered by using either Statement alone
  3. cThe Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
  4. dThe Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) The Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone

Statement I alone allows infinite pairs where n = 1 and m > 1, and Statement II alone allows multiple factor pairs of 24, but combining both yields the unique solution m = 24 and n = 1.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Statement I states m + n > mn and m > n for natural numbers. For any natural number m > 1, setting n = 1 gives m + 1 > m, which is always true. Thus, m can be 2, 3, 4, etc., giving infinite solutions.
  • Statement I alone is insufficient to find unique values of m and n.
✗ Option (b)
  • Statement II states mn = 24. Since m and n are natural numbers, the possible pairs (m, n) are (24, 1), (12, 2), (8, 3), (6, 4), (4, 6), (3, 8), (2, 12), and (1, 24).
  • Since there are multiple possible pairs, Statement II alone is also insufficient.
✓ Option (c)
  • From Statement I, for natural numbers, m + n > mn is possible if and only if at least one of the numbers is 1. Since m > n, we must have n = 1.
  • Substituting n = 1 into Statement II (mn = 24) gives m × 1 = 24, which uniquely determines m = 24 and n = 1.
  • Together, the statements give a unique answer, so both statements together are necessary and sufficient.
✗ Option (d)
  • Combining both statements yields a single unique pair m = 24 and n = 1.
  • Therefore, stating that the question cannot be answered even using both statements together is incorrect.

Concept to know

  • Property of Natural Numbers Inequality: For natural numbers m and n, the inequality m + n > mn holds if and only if at least one of the numbers is equal to 1.
  • Algebraic Factorization Trick: The inequality mn - m - n < 0 can be rewritten as (m - 1)(n - 1) < 1. For natural numbers, (m - 1) and (n - 1) are non-negative integers, so their product can only be 0, implying m = 1 or n = 1.
  • Order Constraint: Since m > n and n is a natural number, n must take the smallest natural number value, which is n = 1.
  • Data Sufficiency Criterion: A statement or combination of statements is sufficient only if it narrows down the possible answers to exactly one unique value.

Related facts for revision

  • Related equation: m + n = mn for positive integers has only one solution, which is m = 2 and n = 2.
  • Discrete Domain Analysis: CSAT questions specifying domains like natural numbers or integers often rely on boundary values like 1 or 0.
  • Factoring quadratic forms in integer equations using Simon's Favorite Factoring Trick: xy + ax + by + ab = (x + b)(y + a).
How UPSC tests this

Ability to analyze algebraic inequalities over discrete sets (natural numbers) and apply Data Sufficiency principles.

Trap: Assuming m + n > mn has no solution for natural numbers, or forgetting that 1 is a natural number which makes m + n > mn hold for all m > 1 when n = 1.

More Data Sufficiency PYQs

All Data Sufficiency questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.