UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q59 · Data Sufficiency
A Question is given followed by two Statements I and II. Consider the Question and the Statements.
Question :
What are the values of m and n, where m and n are natural numbers?
Statement-I :
m + n > mn and m > n.
Statement-II :
The product of m and n is 24.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?
- aThe Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone
- bThe Question can be answered by using either Statement alone
- cThe Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
- dThe Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement I alone allows infinite pairs where n = 1 and m > 1, and Statement II alone allows multiple factor pairs of 24, but combining both yields the unique solution m = 24 and n = 1.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I states m + n > mn and m > n for natural numbers. For any natural number m > 1, setting n = 1 gives m + 1 > m, which is always true. Thus, m can be 2, 3, 4, etc., giving infinite solutions.
- Statement I alone is insufficient to find unique values of m and n.
- Statement II states mn = 24. Since m and n are natural numbers, the possible pairs (m, n) are (24, 1), (12, 2), (8, 3), (6, 4), (4, 6), (3, 8), (2, 12), and (1, 24).
- Since there are multiple possible pairs, Statement II alone is also insufficient.
- From Statement I, for natural numbers, m + n > mn is possible if and only if at least one of the numbers is 1. Since m > n, we must have n = 1.
- Substituting n = 1 into Statement II (mn = 24) gives m × 1 = 24, which uniquely determines m = 24 and n = 1.
- Together, the statements give a unique answer, so both statements together are necessary and sufficient.
- Combining both statements yields a single unique pair m = 24 and n = 1.
- Therefore, stating that the question cannot be answered even using both statements together is incorrect.
Concept to know
- Property of Natural Numbers Inequality: For natural numbers m and n, the inequality m + n > mn holds if and only if at least one of the numbers is equal to 1.
- Algebraic Factorization Trick: The inequality mn - m - n < 0 can be rewritten as (m - 1)(n - 1) < 1. For natural numbers, (m - 1) and (n - 1) are non-negative integers, so their product can only be 0, implying m = 1 or n = 1.
- Order Constraint: Since m > n and n is a natural number, n must take the smallest natural number value, which is n = 1.
- Data Sufficiency Criterion: A statement or combination of statements is sufficient only if it narrows down the possible answers to exactly one unique value.
Related facts for revision
- Related equation: m + n = mn for positive integers has only one solution, which is m = 2 and n = 2.
- Discrete Domain Analysis: CSAT questions specifying domains like natural numbers or integers often rely on boundary values like 1 or 0.
- Factoring quadratic forms in integer equations using Simon's Favorite Factoring Trick: xy + ax + by + ab = (x + b)(y + a).
Ability to analyze algebraic inequalities over discrete sets (natural numbers) and apply Data Sufficiency principles.
Trap: Assuming m + n > mn has no solution for natural numbers, or forgetting that 1 is a natural number which makes m + n > mn hold for all m > 1 when n = 1.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.