UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q20 · Numeracy
A, B, C working independently can do a piece of work in 8, 16 and 12 days respectively. A alone works on Monday, B alone works on Tuesday, C alone works on Wednesday; A alone, again works on Thursday and so on. Consider the following statements :
1. The work will be finished on Thursday.
2. The work will be finished in 10 days.
Which of the above statements is/are correct?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement 1 is correct because the work gets completed on Day 11 which is a Thursday, while Statement 2 is incorrect as total time taken is 11 days.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Assume total work as 48 units, which is the LCM of 8, 16, and 12.
- Daily efficiencies are A = 6 units, B = 3 units, C = 4 units, giving 13 units completed every 3-day cycle.
- In 3 full cycles (9 days from Mon to Tue), 39 units are done. Day 10 (Wed) adds 6 units by A (45 total), and Day 11 (Thu) adds the remaining 3 units by B, finishing the work on Thursday.
- By the end of Day 10 (Wednesday), total work completed is 39 + 6 = 45 units out of 48 units.
- Since 3 units remain, B must work on Day 11 to finish the job.
- Hence, the total time required to complete the work is 11 days, not 10 days.
Concept to know
- Assume total work as the Least Common Multiple (LCM) of individual completion times to work with integers instead of fractions.
- Calculate daily efficiency (units per day) by dividing total work by individual completion time.
- Group repetitive sequential working days into cycles and find the cumulative work done per cycle.
- Divide total work by work per cycle to find completed full cycles and remainder work.
- Track the remaining work day-by-day along with the calendar days of the week to find the exact end day and total duration.
Related facts for revision
- Alternate days work problems where changing the starting person changes the total days required.
- Pipes and cisterns problems with alternate opening of inlet and outlet pipes.
- Efficiency change problems where individual work rates increase or decrease after specific intervals.
- Negative work problems where one person destroys work on alternate days.
Testing efficiency-based time and work calculations involving cyclic alternate working patterns.
Trap: Candidates often miscount days of the week by assuming a 7-day week cycle instead of tracking the actual day-by-day calendar sequence.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.