EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q21 · Comprehension

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ21
SubjectComprehension

To tackle the problem of pollution in cities, policy makers think that drastic actions like temporary use of odd-even number scheme for vehicles, closing schools, factories, construction activities, and banning the use of certain type of vehicles are a way forward. Even then the air is not clean. Vehicles more than 15 years old comprise one percent of the total; and taking them off the road will not make any difference. Banning certain fuels and car types arbitrarily is not proper. Diesel engines produce more PM 2.5 and less CO2 than petrol or CNG engines. On the other hand, both diesel and CNG engines produce more NOx than petrol engines. No one has measured the amount of NOx that CNG engines are emitting. Arbitrary bans on vehicles that have passed mandated fitness tests and periodic pollution tests are unfair. What is needed is the scientific and reliable information about the source of pollutants on a continuing basis and the technologies that will work to reduce pollution from them.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and rational implication conveyed by the passage?

  1. aArbitrary curbs on vehicles to reduce pollution are difficult to implement.
  2. bKnee-jerk reactions cannot solve the problem of pollution but an evidence-based approach will be more effective.
  3. cA heavy penalty should be enforced on those driving without periodic pollution tests.
  4. dIn the absence of laws to deal with the problems of pollution, the administration tends to make arbitrary decisions.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) Knee-jerk reactions cannot solve the problem of pollution but an evidence-based approach will be more effective.

The passage highlights that ad-hoc, arbitrary measures fail to clean the air and explicitly advocates for continuous scientific data and evidence-based technological solutions.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • The passage states that arbitrary curbs are improper and unfair, not that they are difficult to implement.
  • The difficulty of implementation is nowhere discussed or implied in the text.
✓ Option (b)
  • The passage explicitly criticizes arbitrary and temporary measures like odd-even schemes and vehicle bans as ineffective knee-jerk reactions.
  • It concludes by asserting the need for continuous scientific, reliable data on pollutant sources and effective technology, which directly defines an evidence-based approach.
✗ Option (c)
  • The passage mentions periodic pollution tests only to highlight that vehicles passing them face unfair arbitrary bans.
  • It does not recommend heavy penalties for driving without tests, making this an unstated policy recommendation.
✗ Option (d)
  • The passage notes that policy makers take arbitrary decisions, but it never attributes this to an absence of laws.
  • It highlights a lack of scientific information and pollutant measurement rather than a statutory legislative vacuum.

Concept to know

  • Identify the core argument by differentiating between the author's critique of current ad-hoc methods and the proposed constructive solution.
  • Distinguish between logical implication (what necessarily follows from the facts presented) and external assumptions or far-fetched inferences.
  • Match thematic synonyms: temporary and arbitrary actions correspond to knee-jerk reactions, while scientific and reliable information corresponds to an evidence-based approach.
  • Eliminate options that introduce unmentioned causes like lack of laws or unmentioned policy measures like heavy fines.
  • Focus on the concluding sentence of the passage, as it frequently contains the primary thesis or recommended path forward.

Related facts for revision

  • Distinguishing main idea questions from logical implication and critical inference questions.
  • Passages contrasting emergency ad-hoc bans with long-term scientific and technological solutions.
  • Identifying extreme policy traps in options that go beyond the given passage boundary.
  • Mapping qualitative descriptors in options back to specific evidence provided in the text.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to synthesize the author's central thesis and recognize precise conceptual equivalents for key terms.

Trap: Option (d) attracts candidates because arbitrary decisions are mentioned, but attributing them to an absence of laws goes beyond the text.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.