UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q1 · Comprehension
We often hear about conflicts among different States in India over river waters. Of the 20 major river systems, 14 are already water-stressed; 75% of the population lives in water-stressed regions, a third of whom live in water-scarce areas. Climate change, the demands of rising population and the need for agriculture to keep pace, and increased rate of urbanization and industrialization will exacerbate water stress. According to the Constitution of India, water is a State subject and not that of the Union, except for regulation of inter-State rivers. Key to ensuring balance between competing demands of various stakeholders is a basin-based approach to allocate water amongst constituent regions and States. Allocating fair share of water to them requires assessments based on objective criteria, such as specificities of the river basin, size of dependent population, existing water use and demand, efficiency of use, projected future use, etc. while ensuring the environmental needs of the river and aquifers.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most rational, practical and immediate action required to ensure fair and equitable allocation of water to different stakeholders?
- aA national, pragmatic, legal and policy framework for water allocation should be made.
- bAll river systems of the country should be linked and huge aquifers created.
- cWater channels between regions of water surplus and regions of water deficit should be created.
- dTo mitigate water crisis, water demand of sectors such as agriculture and industry should be reduced.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
A national, pragmatic, legal, and policy framework directly addresses the constitutional split of powers and provides the objective, basin-based allocation criteria called for in the passage.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage explicitly states that regulation of inter-State rivers involves constitutional provisions while demanding objective criteria and a basin-based approach to allocate water fairly among States and stakeholders.
- Establishing a national, pragmatic, legal, and policy framework directly synthesizes the passage's call for basin-based allocation, constitutional alignment, objective assessment criteria, and environmental protection.
- It represents a comprehensive, rational, practical, and immediate administrative solution rather than an extreme physical engineering project or drastic economic curtailment.
- The passage does not advocate linking all river systems or constructing huge artificial aquifers anywhere in its text.
- Linking all rivers across the entire country is an extreme, capital-intensive, ecologically complex long-term proposal, not an immediate or universally practical action.
- Creating physical water channels inter-linking surplus and deficit regions is a specific engineering intervention not mentioned or suggested in the passage.
- Without an overarching legal and policy framework to define objective allocation criteria, creating channels across State boundaries remains legally unviable and fails to resolve stakeholder disputes.
- The passage explicitly emphasizes the need for agriculture to keep pace with a rising population rather than simply reducing sector demand.
- Arbitrarily reducing water demand of vital economic sectors like agriculture and industry is impractical and contradicts the passage's emphasis on efficiency of use and meeting projected future demand.
Concept to know
- Identify the prompt requirement: questions asking for the most rational, practical, and immediate action require a balanced, policy-oriented solution directly anchored in the text.
- Evaluate scope and feasibility: correct options in CSAT comprehension synthesize the core arguments of the author without introducing unstated extreme measures.
- Distinguish governance frameworks from hardware solutions: complex inter-State governance issues require legal, policy, and administrative structures before physical engineering interventions can succeed.
- Avoid extreme actions: proposals suggesting drastic cuts to food production capacity or altering all natural river systems are typically incorrect distractors.
- Synthesize textual constraints: align constitutional responsibilities of Union and State levels mentioned in the text with an overarching national governance policy.
Related facts for revision
- Questions asking for Most Rational and Practical Action: focus on feasible, structured policy measures supported by the text rather than radical physical overhauls.
- Questions asking for Logical Corollary: require identifying the logical next step or consequence directly flowing from the facts given in the passage.
- Questions asking for Main Idea or Crux: require identifying the primary thematic message of the author while ignoring supporting statistics and secondary details.
- Distinction between passage facts and external knowledge: candidates must not select options based on real-world schemes like the Inter-Linking of Rivers project unless explicitly supported by the passage.
Evaluating the ability to extract the most practical policy recommendation from a text detailing multi-faceted socio-legal constraints.
Trap: Options (b) and (c) represent real-world proposals like river inter-linking that tempt candidates with prior general knowledge, even though the passage never mentions them and emphasizes objective policy criteria instead.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.