EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q39 · Data Sufficiency

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ39
SubjectData Sufficiency

Consider the following including the Question and the Statements :
There are 5 members A, B, C, D, E in a family.
Question : What is the relation of E to B ?
Statement-1 : A and B are a married couple.
Statement-2 : D is the father of C.
Statement-3 : E is D's son.
Statement-4 : A and C are sisters.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and Statements ?

  1. aStatement-1, Statement-2 and Statement-3 are sufficient to answer the Question.
  2. bStatement-1, Statement-3 and Statement-4 are sufficient to answer the Question.
  3. cAll four statements together are sufficient to answer the Question.
  4. dAll four statements are not sufficient to answer the Question.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) All four statements together are sufficient to answer the Question.

All four statements together uniquely deduce that E is the brother-in-law (wife's brother) of B.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Statements 1, 2, and 3 provide information about married couple (A, B) and family group (C, D, E).
  • Without Statement 4, there is no link connecting A or B to C, D, or E.
  • Hence, these three statements are insufficient.
✗ Option (b)
  • Statements 1, 3, and 4 connect A with B and A with C, and state that E is D's son.
  • Without Statement 2 (D is the father of C), the connection of D and E to C and A remains unknown.
  • Hence, these three statements are insufficient.
✓ Option (c)
  • From Statement 4, A and C are sisters, so A is female and C is female.
  • From Statement 1, A and B are a married couple, which means B is male (A's husband).
  • From Statement 2, D is father of C, so D is also father of A.
  • From Statement 3, E is D's son, so E is male and is brother to C and A.
  • Combining all four statements shows E is the brother of B's wife A (i.e. E is B's brother-in-law).
✗ Option (d)
  • All four statements together successfully yield a unique and definite relation of E to B.
  • Therefore, stating that all four statements are not sufficient is incorrect.

Concept to know

  • Data Sufficiency in Blood Relations requires determining a unique relation with definitive gender and generational links.
  • Step 1: Identify the exact direction of the question, which asks for the relation of E to B (who E is to B).
  • Step 2: Use sibling and parental descriptors to assign gender (e.g. sisters implies female, son/father implies male).
  • Step 3: Combine disjoint sets of information using bridging statements (Statement 4 bridges couple A-B with parent-child set D-C-E).
  • Step 4: Check if any statement can be eliminated without losing the chain of connections.

Related facts for revision

  • Gender Assignment Trap: Married couple terms alone do not specify who is husband and who is wife until one partner's gender is fixed via sibling/parent relations.
  • Direction of Relationship: Relation of E to B means E's identity relative to B, not B's identity relative to E.
  • Data Sufficiency Elimination: If removing any single statement breaks the logical chain connecting the target entities, all statements are necessary.
How UPSC tests this

Logical deduction, family tree mapping, and data sufficiency evaluation across multiple constraints.

Trap: Assuming spouse genders in Statement 1 before deriving A's female gender from Statement 4, or assuming D is connected to A without Statement 2.

More Data Sufficiency PYQs

All Data Sufficiency questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.