UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q39 · Data Sufficiency
Consider the following including the Question and the Statements :
There are 5 members A, B, C, D, E in a family.
Question : What is the relation of E to B ?
Statement-1 : A and B are a married couple.
Statement-2 : D is the father of C.
Statement-3 : E is D's son.
Statement-4 : A and C are sisters.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and Statements ?
- aStatement-1, Statement-2 and Statement-3 are sufficient to answer the Question.
- bStatement-1, Statement-3 and Statement-4 are sufficient to answer the Question.
- cAll four statements together are sufficient to answer the Question.
- dAll four statements are not sufficient to answer the Question.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
All four statements together uniquely deduce that E is the brother-in-law (wife's brother) of B.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statements 1, 2, and 3 provide information about married couple (A, B) and family group (C, D, E).
- Without Statement 4, there is no link connecting A or B to C, D, or E.
- Hence, these three statements are insufficient.
- Statements 1, 3, and 4 connect A with B and A with C, and state that E is D's son.
- Without Statement 2 (D is the father of C), the connection of D and E to C and A remains unknown.
- Hence, these three statements are insufficient.
- From Statement 4, A and C are sisters, so A is female and C is female.
- From Statement 1, A and B are a married couple, which means B is male (A's husband).
- From Statement 2, D is father of C, so D is also father of A.
- From Statement 3, E is D's son, so E is male and is brother to C and A.
- Combining all four statements shows E is the brother of B's wife A (i.e. E is B's brother-in-law).
- All four statements together successfully yield a unique and definite relation of E to B.
- Therefore, stating that all four statements are not sufficient is incorrect.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency in Blood Relations requires determining a unique relation with definitive gender and generational links.
- Step 1: Identify the exact direction of the question, which asks for the relation of E to B (who E is to B).
- Step 2: Use sibling and parental descriptors to assign gender (e.g. sisters implies female, son/father implies male).
- Step 3: Combine disjoint sets of information using bridging statements (Statement 4 bridges couple A-B with parent-child set D-C-E).
- Step 4: Check if any statement can be eliminated without losing the chain of connections.
Related facts for revision
- Gender Assignment Trap: Married couple terms alone do not specify who is husband and who is wife until one partner's gender is fixed via sibling/parent relations.
- Direction of Relationship: Relation of E to B means E's identity relative to B, not B's identity relative to E.
- Data Sufficiency Elimination: If removing any single statement breaks the logical chain connecting the target entities, all statements are necessary.
Logical deduction, family tree mapping, and data sufficiency evaluation across multiple constraints.
Trap: Assuming spouse genders in Statement 1 before deriving A's female gender from Statement 4, or assuming D is connected to A without Statement 2.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.