UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q13 · Comprehension
Many people are not eating the right food. For some, it is simply a decision to stick with food they enjoy but which is not too healthy. This is leading to an increase in non-communicable diseases. This in turn leads to major burden on our health-care systems that have the potential to derail the economic progress which is essential for the poor to improve their lives. For others, it is about limited access to nutritious food or a lack of affordability, leading to monotonous diets that do not provide the daily nutrients for them to develop fully. Part of the reason nutrition is under threat worldwide is that our food systems are not properly responding to nutritional needs. Somewhere along that long road from farm to fork, there are serious detours taking place.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crux of the passage?
- aThe scheme of Universal Basic Income should be implemented worldwide as a way of poverty alleviation.
- bWe must place food-based nutrition at the centre of our policy debate.
- cNutritional status of food should be improved by creating appropriate genetically modified crops.
- dUsing modern food processing technologies, we must fortify food items with required nutrient elements.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that food systems worldwide fail to respond to nutritional needs, impacting public health and economic progress, which requires placing food-based nutrition at the core of policy debates.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage mentions limited access and affordability of food, but it nowhere suggests Universal Basic Income as a solution.
- Recommending a specific economic intervention like UBI goes beyond the scope of the given text.
- The author emphasizes that food systems from farm to fork are failing to address nutritional needs, leading to non-communicable diseases and economic burden.
- Placing food-based nutrition at the center of policy debate directly reflects the core takeaway of restructuring food systems to meet public health needs.
- Genetically modified crops are not mentioned or implied anywhere in the text.
- This option introduces an external technological solution not supported by the passage.
- Food fortification through modern processing techniques is not discussed in the passage.
- While bio-fortification is a real-world policy tool, selecting it relies on outside general knowledge rather than textual evidence.
Concept to know
- To find the crux or main takeaway of a passage, identify the primary issue raised by the author and the broad directional change required.
- Distinguish between what is explicitly stated or implied by the passage versus external real-world solutions derived from General Studies knowledge.
- Avoid options that introduce specific technical solutions like GM crops, fortification, or UBI if they are absent from the text.
- Evaluate the scope: the passage connects food choices, affordability, food system failures, non-communicable diseases, and economic development to argue for a comprehensive policy shift towards food-based nutrition.
Related facts for revision
- Crux and Main Idea Questions: Focus on the overall message of the excerpt rather than isolated facts or narrow examples.
- Assumption Questions: Look for unstated premises that must hold true for the author's logic to remain valid.
- Inference Questions: Draw strictly logical conclusions directly supported by the passage without adding outside information.
- Out-of-Scope Trap: Eliminate choices that represent correct real-world facts but lack direct grounding in the passage text.
Ability to synthesize paragraph-level arguments and identify the core policy recommendation implicit in the passage without relying on external subject knowledge.
Trap: Options (c) and (d) present familiar General Studies solutions (GM crops and food fortification) that tempt candidates, but are completely absent from the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.