UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q51 · Comprehension
Sourcing food from non-agricultural lands (uncultivated systems such as forests, wetlands, pastures, etc) in addition to agricultural lands enables a systemic approach to food consumption. It allows rural and tribal communities to sustain themselves for the whole year and steer clear of natural disasters and season-induced shortfalls of agricultural food. Since the productivity of trees is often more resilient to adverse weather conditions than annual crops, forest foods often provide a safety net during periods of food shortages caused by crop failure; forest foods also make important contributions during seasonal crop production gaps.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and rational message conveyed by the author of the passage?
- aFood yielding trees should replace other trees in rural and tribal areas and community owned lands.
- bFood security cannot be ensured in India with the present practice of conventional agriculture.
- cWastelands and degraded areas in India should be converted into agroforestry systems to help the poor.
- dAgroecosystems should be developed in addition to or along with conventional agriculture.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly emphasizes sourcing food from uncultivated non-agricultural systems in addition to agricultural lands to build resilience and seasonal safety nets.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage advocates utilizing non-agricultural lands alongside agricultural lands but never suggests replacing existing non-food trees with food-yielding trees.
- The term replace represents an extreme prescriptive leap not supported by the text.
- The text highlights seasonal gaps and climate vulnerability of annual crops, but it does not state that conventional agriculture completely fails food security in India.
- This statement makes an absolute sweeping generalization about food security in India that goes beyond the author's scope.
- The passage lists uncultivated systems like forests, wetlands, and pastures, but makes no mention of converting India's wastelands or degraded areas.
- Introducing specific land categories like wastelands is an outside assumption not discussed in the text.
- The passage directly states that sourcing food from non-agricultural systems in addition to agricultural lands enables a systemic approach.
- Developing agroecosystems along with conventional agriculture captures the central theme of integrating diverse resilient food sources to survive shocks.
Concept to know
- Identify the core synthesis of the author by examining how complementary ideas are joined using phrases like in addition to.
- Eliminate options containing extreme prescriptive terms such as replace or absolute assertions like cannot be ensured.
- Beware of options introducing specific outside entities or geographical scopes not mentioned in the passage, such as Indian wastelands.
- Distinguish between a supplementary recommendation and a total condemnation of conventional methods.
- Select the option that accurately paraphrases the main logical message while remaining faithful to the passage's boundary.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea versus Supporting Fact: Differentiating between illustrative examples of resilience and the core policy takeaway.
- Scope Overreach Trap: How test setters introduce extra terms like wastelands or India to distract candidates.
- Degree of Certainty Distractors: Identifying words like cannot, always, or replace that make an option overly rigid.
- Paraphrasing Identification: Mapping passage terms like non-agricultural lands in addition to agricultural lands to agroecosystems along with conventional agriculture.
Ability to extract the central rational message of a passage without relying on external knowledge or extreme interpretations.
Trap: Option (b) attracts candidates who over-interpret crop vulnerability as a total failure of conventional agriculture, but option (d) correctly reflects the additive approach stated in the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.