UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q2 · Comprehension
More than half of Indian women and almost a quarter of Indian men of working age suffer from anaemia. According to studies, they are anywhere from 5 – 15% less productive than they could be, as a result thereof. India also has the largest tuberculosis burden in the world, costing 170 million workdays to the country annually. But what is just as important as lost productivity now is lost potential in the future. It is becoming increasingly clear that on many measures of cognitive ability, malnourished Indian children perform two or three times worse than their adequately nourished peers. For an economy that will be more dependent on highly skilled workers, this poses a significant challenge. And it is one that really should be addressed given India's demographic outlook.
Which one of the following statements best reflects what is implied by the passage?
- aEducation system must be strengthened in rural areas.
- bLarge scale and effective implementation of skill development programme is the need of the hour.
- cFor economic development, health and nutrition of only skilled workers needs special attention.
- dFor rapid economic growth as envisaged by us, attention should be paid to health and nutrition of the people.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage connects health and nutrition deficits like anaemia, tuberculosis, and child malnutrition to lost productivity and reduced cognitive potential, implying that public health and nutrition are vital for economic growth.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage makes no reference to the education system or rural areas specifically.
- Bringing in rural education introduces external information not stated or implied by the text.
- Although skilled workers are mentioned, skill development training programs are not discussed in the text.
- The passage identifies poor health and malnutrition as the root cause of cognitive and productivity losses, not the absence of vocational training.
- The word only makes this option overly restrictive, whereas the passage discusses working-age adults broadly and malnourished children.
- Focusing exclusively on skilled workers ignores the foundational health needs of children and the broader workforce highlighted in the text.
- The passage directly links anaemia, tuberculosis, and child malnourishment to lost workdays and reduced cognitive performance that threaten future economic potential.
- It logically implies that prioritizing public health and nutrition is essential to achieve India's desired economic growth and leverage its demographic outlook.
Concept to know
- Synthesize core cause-and-effect relationships presented across the passage to identify the main theme.
- Distinguish between explicit statements and implicit conclusions that logically flow from the provided premises.
- Evaluate the scope of options to eliminate choices that introduce external topics not supported by the text.
- Watch out for restrictive qualifiers such as only, strictly, or must which often narrow an option incorrectly.
- Connect supporting facts like disease burden and cognitive deficits to the passage's broader economic conclusion.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea questions require identifying the author's central argument rather than minor supporting details.
- Logical Inference questions require identifying unstated conclusions that necessarily follow from the text.
- Crucial Message questions focus on the actionable takeaway intended by the author.
- Recognizing scope-shift traps where options mention real-world concepts like skill development that are absent from the passage.
Ability to draw logical inferences regarding public policy and economic potential from human development data.
Trap: Option (b) is a classic trap because skill development is a familiar policy response to skilled workforce needs, but health and nutrition is the actual root cause addressed in the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.