EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q31 · Comprehension

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ31
SubjectComprehension

In India, the segregation of municipal waste at source is rare. Recycling is mostly with the informal sector. More than three-fourths of the municipal budget goes into collection and transportation, which leaves very little for processing/resource recovery and disposal. Where does waste-to-energy fit into all this ? Ideally it fits in the chain after segregation (between wet waste and the rest), collection, recycling, and before getting to the landfill. Which technology is most appropriate in converting waste to energy depends on what is in the waste (that is biodegradable versus non-biodegradable component) and its calorific value. The biodegradable component of India's municipal solid waste is a little over 50 per cent, and biomethanation offers a major solution for processing this.

Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Collection, processing and segregation of municipal waste should be with government agencies.
2. Resource recovery and recycling require technological inputs that can be best handled by private sector enterprises.
Which of the assumptions given above is/are correct ?

  1. a1 only
  2. b2 only
  3. cBoth 1 and 2
  4. dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Neither statement is a necessary unstated assumption of the passage, as the text describes current operational facts without advocating whether government or private entities should manage waste operations.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement 1
  • The passage states that municipal budgets are heavily spent on collection and transportation, but it nowhere assumes or mandates that these tasks should strictly belong to government agencies.
  • It explicitly notes that recycling is currently handled mostly by the informal sector, which directly contradicts any assumption of absolute government ownership.
✗ Statement 2
  • The passage highlights that selecting the right waste-to-energy technology depends on waste composition and calorific value.
  • It makes no explicit or implicit claim that technological inputs can be best handled by private sector enterprises.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated premise that must be true for the author's primary argument to logically hold.
  • Extraneous real-world knowledge regarding privatization or public sector roles must be completely excluded during passage evaluation.
  • Prescriptive claims containing normative words like 'should' or 'best handled' require direct contextual justification within the text.
  • The negation test helps evaluate validity: if negating a statement does not break the passage logic, the statement is not an essential assumption.
  • Differentiate strictly between descriptive statements of fact in the passage and implicit assumptions made by the author.

Related facts for revision

  • Assumption vs Inference: An inference is a logical conclusion derived from text facts, whereas an assumption is a hidden prerequisite premise.
  • Negation Technique in Critical Reasoning: Negating a valid assumption destabilizes the core argument of the passage.
  • Avoidance of Policy Bias: Refraining from applying personal opinions on government administration or market privatization during CSAT reading comprehension.
How UPSC tests this

Critical reasoning ability to distinguish factual text descriptions from normative unstated assumptions without applying external bias.

Trap: Candidates often choose option (b) or (c) by projecting real-world policy opinions about private sector efficiency or government duties rather than strictly relying on the text.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.