UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q68 · Numeracy
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T each one of whom has to be assigned one task. Neither P nor Q can be assigned Task-1. Task-2 must be assigned to either R or S. In how many ways can the assignment be done?
- a6
- b12
- c18
- d24
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Task-2 has 2 choices (R or S), Task-1 then has 2 valid choices among the remaining persons, and the remaining 3 tasks can be assigned in 3! = 6 ways, giving 2 × 2 × 6 = 24 total ways.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Incorrect because 6 is only the number of permutations (3!) for the remaining 3 unconstrained persons and tasks after choices for Task-1 and Task-2 are fixed.
- Incorrect because 12 accounts for assigning Task-2 to only one specific person (either R or S), failing to add the equal number of cases for the second choice.
- Incorrect because 18 results from miscounting the available choices for Task-1 or incorrectly combining addition and multiplication.
- Task-2 can be assigned to either R or S, giving 2 choices.
- For Task-1, neither P nor Q can be chosen, leaving 2 eligible persons out of the remaining 4.
- The remaining 3 tasks can be assigned to the remaining 3 persons in 3! = 6 ways, making total ways = 2 × 2 × 6 = 24.
Concept to know
- Fundamental Principle of Multiplication: If a process consists of multiple sequential independent choices, the total number of ways is the product of the number of options at each stage.
- Constraint-First Approach: When solving permutation problems with restricted conditions, always fill the positions with the most restrictive constraints first.
- Step 1 - Assign Task-2: Choose a person for Task-2 from the restricted set {R, S}, which offers exactly 2 options.
- Step 2 - Assign Task-1: From the remaining 4 persons, exclude P and Q, leaving exactly 2 eligible persons for Task-1.
- Step 3 - Assign Remaining Tasks: The remaining 3 tasks can be distributed among the remaining 3 persons in 3! = 3 × 2 × 1 = 6 ways.
- Total Calculation: Total valid arrangements = (Ways for Task-2) × (Ways for Task-1) × (Ways for remaining tasks) = 2 × 2 × 6 = 24.
Related facts for revision
- Restricted Permutations: Problems where specific elements cannot occupy designated positions.
- Derangements: Finding arrangements where no element appears in its original or natural spot.
- Slot Method: Filling constrained slots first before arranging unconstrained elements.
- Multiplication vs Addition Rule: Multiplying independent sequential events versus adding mutually exclusive cases.
Permutations with multiple constraints and systematic application of the Fundamental Principle of Counting.
Trap: Candidates often forget that after assigning Task-2 to R (or S), one non-P/Q person is used up, leaving T plus the unassigned person of {R, S} as 2 valid options for Task-1.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.