UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q77 · Reasoning
Consider the following statements in respect of five candidates P, Q, R, S and T. Two statements are true and one statement is false.
True Statement : One of P and Q was selected for the job.
False Statement: At least one of R and S was selected for the job.
True Statement: At most two of R, S and T were selected for the job.
Which of the following conclusions can be drawn?
1. At least four were selected for the job.
2. S was selected for the job.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Neither conclusion 1 nor conclusion 2 follows because at most 2 candidates were selected and S was definitely not selected.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement 1 gives exactly 1 selected candidate from {P, Q}.
- False Statement 2 implies that neither R nor S was selected (0 candidates from {R, S}).
- Candidate T may or may not be selected, so total selected candidates can be at most 2 (1 from {P, Q} + 0 from {R, S} + 1 from {T}), making Conclusion 1 incorrect.
- The statement 'At least one of R and S was selected' is explicitly given as FALSE.
- The negation of this statement must be TRUE, which means neither R nor S was selected.
- Hence, S was definitely NOT selected, making Conclusion 2 incorrect.
- Conclusion 1 is false because the maximum number of selected candidates is 2.
- Conclusion 2 is false because S was not selected for the job.
- Therefore, both conclusions cannot be true simultaneously.
- From the true premise of Statement 1, selected count from {P, Q} is 1.
- From the false premise of Statement 2, selected count from {R, S} is 0, so S is not selected.
- Total selected candidates is either 1 or 2, so neither Conclusion 1 nor Conclusion 2 can be drawn.
Concept to know
- Logical Negation Rule: If a compound statement is FALSE, its logical negation is guaranteed to be TRUE.
- Negating Existential Quantification: The negation of 'at least one of A or B' is 'neither A nor B'.
- Bounded Selection Sets: Calculating the minimum and maximum possible selected candidates across disjoint subsets.
- Evaluating Dependent Statements: Statement 3 states at most 2 of R, S, T were selected, which is automatically satisfied since R = 0, S = 0, and T can be at most 1.
Related facts for revision
- Logical Deduction problems involving truth-teller and liar puzzles.
- Set theory concepts involving unions, intersections, and set complements.
- Categorical syllogisms with existential vs universal quantifiers.
Logical deduction ability to correctly negate a false premise and determine variable boundaries.
Trap: Candidates often misread 'False Statement' as a true premise, mistakenly assuming R or S was selected.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.