UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q52 · Comprehension
While awareness on use/misuse and abuse of antibiotics is common knowledge, as is the impact of dosing poultry with antibiotics, the environmental impact of antibiotics-manufacturing companies not treating their waste has scarcely been discussed at any length or seriousness thus far. Pollution from antibiotics factories is fuelling the rise of drug-resistant infections. The occurrence of drug-resistant bacteria surrounding the pharma manufacturing plants is well known.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and practical message conveyed by the passage?
- aIt is necessary to put proper effluent treatment protocols in place.
- bIt is necessary to promote environmental awareness among people.
- cSpread of drug-resistant bacteria cannot be done away with, as it is inherent in modern medical care.
- dPharma-manufacturing companies should be set up in remote rural areas, away from crowded towns and cities.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage identifies untreated industrial waste from pharma factories as the driver of drug-resistant infections, making effluent treatment the direct practical solution.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage explicitly states that antibiotics manufacturing companies not treating their waste leads to pollution that fuels drug-resistant infections.
- Implementing proper effluent treatment protocols directly tackles the root cause of environmental contamination highlighted in the text.
- The text notes that general awareness regarding antibiotic use is already common knowledge.
- Promoting general public awareness does not solve the specific industrial issue of untreated factory waste.
- This option presents a defeatist stance that contradicts the passage premise.
- The passage links drug resistance to actionable industrial pollution, implying the spread can be checked by proper waste management.
- Relocating factories to rural areas merely shifts the site of environmental contamination without eliminating untreated toxic discharge.
- This is an impractical and illogical measure that fails to solve the pollution problem.
Concept to know
- In practical message questions, match the key recommendation directly to the main cause of the problem stated in the text.
- Identify the core breakdown described by the author, which here is the failure of factories to treat industrial waste.
- Eliminate options that offer broad, vague solutions like general public awareness when the issue requires targeted regulatory action.
- Reject options that displace a problem geographically rather than rectifying the underlying process.
- Avoid defeatist choices claiming a problem cannot be solved if the passage highlights concrete preventable causes.
Related facts for revision
- Logical Corollary questions requiring actionable policy conclusions.
- Distinction between general takeaway and specific practical recommendation.
- Identifying tone and underlying assumptions in environmental policy passages.
Ability to extract an actionable and logical solution derived directly from the explicit cause-and-effect relationship in the text.
Trap: Choosing broad options like option b or displacement options like option d that sound plausible in general discussion but fail to solve the specific issue identified.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.