UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q38 · Reasoning
Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ38
SubjectReasoning
Consider the following statements :
1. A is older than B.
2. C and D are of the same age.
3. E is the youngest.
4. F is younger than D.
5. F is older than A.
How many statements given above are required to determine the oldest person/persons ?
- aOnly two
- bOnly three
- cOnly four
- dAll five
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) All five
All five statements are required to link all six individuals (A, B, C, D, E, F) into a single chain and confirm C and D as the oldest.
Statement-by-statement analysis
✗ Option (a)
- Only two statements leave most individuals unlinked.
- It is impossible to determine the relative positions of all six people with only two statements.
✗ Option (b)
- Three statements can at most link four individuals.
- The remaining two unlinked individuals could potentially be older than everyone else.
✗ Option (c)
- With four statements, one individual remains completely unconstrained.
- For example, omitting Statement 3 leaves E unconstrained, so E could be the oldest person.
✓ Option (d)
- Statement 1 gives A > B.
- Statement 5 gives F > A, combining to F > A > B.
- Statement 4 gives D > F, combining to D > F > A > B.
- Statement 2 gives C = D, combining to C = D > F > A > B.
- Statement 3 specifies E is the youngest, completing the chain C = D > F > A > B > E.
- All five statements are necessary to rule out any unlinked person being older than C and D.
Concept to know
- Represent age relationships as inequalities using greater-than (>) and equal-to (=) symbols.
- To find the unique maximum or top rank, every entity in the set must be constrained relative to the potential maximum.
- If any element is left unconstrained by omitting a statement, that element could theoretically be larger than all others.
- Test data sufficiency by removing each statement one by one to verify if the top position can still be uniquely determined.
- Combine pairwise inequalities transitively: if X > Y and Y > Z, then X > Y > Z.
Related facts for revision
- Data Sufficiency in Order and Ranking problems.
- Transitive property of linear ordering and inequality chains.
- Handling tied positions or equal values in ranking puzzles.
- Min-Max determination with missing information in logical reasoning.
How UPSC tests this
Ability to form complete inequality chains and test data sufficiency across multiple variables.
Trap: Assuming statements about the youngest person or lower-ranked individuals are redundant, forgetting that unconstrained variables can take any position including the top.
← Previous · Q37If 'ZERO' is written as 'CHUR', then how is 'PLAYER' written ?Next · Q39 →Consider the following including the Question and the Statements : There are 5…
More Reasoning PYQs
The weight of X, in kg, is denoted by X. The weights of A, B, C, D, P, Q, R and S are measured. Given: A+B+C+D = 17; A+C = 6; P+Q+S+D = 15; P+Q+R+B = 17; P = R and Q = S. Which one of the following statements is correct?
See the answer & explanation →
Eight persons P, Q, R, S, T, U, V and W sit around a round table in eight different seats placed with equal distance between any two consecutive seats. Both P and R are adjacent to Q. Both T and R are adjacent to S. Both U and W…
See the answer & explanation →
A pattern formed by two characters a and b is repeated more than once in the following string: × b × a × a × × a × bab. What is × × in the 7th and 8th positions from the left in the above string?
See the answer & explanation →
A cut on a solid object divides the object into two parts where the new surfaces thus produced are plane. On the other hand, one single cut can be used to cut more than one object at a time. In an experiment, the total number of…
See the answer & explanation →Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.