UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q33 · Comprehension
There is a claim that organic farming is inherently safer and healthier. The reality is that because the organic farming industry is still young and not well-regulated in India, farmers and consumers, alike, are not only confused about what products are best for them, but sometimes use products in ways that could harm them as well. For example, since organic fertilizers are difficult to obtain on a large scale in India, farmers often use farmyard manure, which may contain toxic chemicals and heavy metals. Certain plant sprays, such as Datura flower and leaf spray, have an element called atropine. If it is not applied in the right dose, it can act on the nervous system of the consumer. Unfortunately, how much and when to use it are not well-researched or regulated issues.
Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Organic farming is inherently unsafe for both farmers and consumers.
2. Farmers and consumers need to be educated about eco-friendly food.
Which of the assumptions given above is/are correct ?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Assumption 2 logically follows because the passage highlights widespread confusion and misuse among farmers and consumers due to a lack of awareness and proper guidance.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage explicitly states there is a claim that organic farming is inherently safer, but current hazards arise due to a lack of regulation, research, and proper dosage.
- Highlighting operational flaws and lack of regulatory oversight in a young industry does not mean organic farming is inherently unsafe in its fundamental nature.
- Therefore, Assumption 1 is an extreme generalization and incorrect.
- The passage notes that farmers and consumers are confused about which products are best and use products in harmful ways.
- The underlying logical premise for addressing this confusion and wrong application is that both groups require education and guidance on eco-friendly food and safe inputs.
- Therefore, Assumption 2 is a valid implicit assumption of the text.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author takes for granted to build their core argument.
- Use the Negation Test: if negating a statement causes the author's logic or recommendation to collapse, that statement is a valid assumption.
- Distinguish between inherent flaws (fundamental character) and operational defects (lack of regulation, research, or training).
- Avoid extreme or absolute terms like inherently, universally, or completely unless directly justified by the text.
- Identify systemic gaps in the passage, such as confusion or lack of knowledge, which naturally imply the need for awareness and education.
Related facts for revision
- Difference between Assumption and Inference: Assumptions are foundational unstated premises, while inferences are logically derived conclusions from given facts.
- Difference between Corollary and Implication: A corollary is a secondary direct consequence, whereas an implication points to unstated future impacts.
- Elimination technique for CSAT Comprehension: Statements containing extreme language or unsupported absolute claims should usually be eliminated.
- Distinguishing main theme from illustrative examples: Treat specific cases like Datura spray or manure as supporting illustrations, not the primary focus.
Identifying unstated assumptions and separating operational deficiencies from inherent flaws in comprehension passages.
Trap: Candidates often choose Option (d) assuming education is not explicitly written in the passage, or Option (c) by confusing current regulation gaps with inherent unsafety.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.