EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q70 · Reasoning

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ70
SubjectReasoning

Consider the following:
I. A + B means A is neither smaller nor equal to B.
II. A – B means A is not greater than B.
III. A × B means A is not smaller than B.
IV. A ÷ B means A is neither greater nor equal to B.
V. A ± B means A is neither smaller nor greater than B.
Statement : P × Q, P – T, T ÷ R, R ± S
Conclusion-1 : Q ± T
Conclusion-2 : S + Q
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Statement and the Conclusions?

  1. aOnly Conclusion-1 follows from the Statement.
  2. bOnly Conclusion-2 follows from the Statement.
  3. cBoth Conclusion-1 and Conclusion-2 follow from the Statement.
  4. dNeither Conclusion-1 nor Conclusion-2 follows from the Statement.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) Only Conclusion-2 follows from the Statement.

Conclusion-1 (Q = T) is only one possibility since Q <= T, while Conclusion-2 (S > Q) is definitely true because Q <= T < R = S yields Q < S.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Conclusion-1 states Q ± T which decodes to Q = T.
  • Combining statements P >= Q and P <= T gives Q <= P <= T, which reduces to Q <= T.
  • Q <= T means Q can be less than T or equal to T, making Q = T uncertain and not definitely true.
✓ Option (b)
  • Conclusion-2 states S + Q which decodes to S > Q.
  • Combining all relations gives the chain Q <= P <= T < R = S.
  • Since Q <= T and T < S (from T < R and R = S), it strictly follows that Q < S, which is equivalent to S > Q.
✗ Option (c)
  • Both conclusions cannot follow because Conclusion-1 is only a possibility, not a definite logical consequence.
  • Only Conclusion-2 holds true under all conditions.
✗ Option (d)
  • Neither follows is incorrect because Conclusion-2 is proved true from the relational chain.

Concept to know

  • Decode mathematical inequality symbols: + means greater than, - means not greater than (less than or equal to), × means not smaller than (greater than or equal to), ÷ means less than, and ± means equal to.
  • Combine individual pairwise inequalities containing common terms into a continuous chain of relations.
  • Apply the transitive property of inequalities: if A <= B and B < C, then A < C.
  • A conclusion in CSAT reasoning must be definitely true in all scenarios to follow from the statements.
  • A non-strict inequality such as Q <= T implies either Q < T or Q = T; taking either condition alone as a definite conclusion is logically invalid.

Related facts for revision

  • Either-Or complementary cases: if individual conclusions Q < T and Q = T are presented together for Q <= T, they form an either-or pair.
  • Opposing sign blockage: when elements face opposite inequality signs like A > B < C, no relation between A and C can be determined.
  • Operator hierarchy: strict inequalities (< or >) dominate non-strict inequalities (<= or >=) along any path in a relational chain.
How UPSC tests this

Testing ability to decode coded symbols, build inequality chains, and distinguish definite deductions from mere possibilities.

Trap: Treating a non-strict inequality (<=) as an exact equality (=), leading to the incorrect acceptance of Conclusion-1.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.