UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q56 · Data Sufficiency
Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ56
SubjectData Sufficiency
Question : Is p greater than q?
Statement-1: p × q is greater than zero.
Statement-2: p^2 is greater than q^2.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?
- aThe Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone.
- bThe Question can be answered by using either Statement alone.
- cThe Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone.
- dThe Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) The Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together.
Even by combining both statements, the relation between p and q depends on whether both variables are positive or negative, giving conflicting answers.
Statement-by-statement analysis
✗ Option (a)
- Statement 1 gives p * q > 0, which means both p and q have the same sign.
- If p = 2 and q = 1, then p * q = 2 > 0 and p > q is True.
- If p = 1 and q = 2, then p * q = 2 > 0 and p > q is False. Hence Statement 1 alone is insufficient.
✗ Option (b)
- Statement 2 gives p^2 > q^2, which means |p| > |q|.
- If p = 2 and q = 1, then 4 > 1 and p > q is True.
- If p = -2 and q = 1, then 4 > 1 but p > q is False (-2 < 1). Hence Statement 2 alone is also insufficient.
✗ Option (c)
- Combining Statement 1 (same sign) and Statement 2 (|p| > |q|):
- If both are positive, let p = 3 and q = 2: p * q = 6 > 0 and 9 > 4; here p > q is True.
- If both are negative, let p = -3 and q = -2: p * q = 6 > 0 and 9 > 4; here p > q is False (-3 < -2).
- Since both True and No outcomes are possible, combining both statements still does not yield a unique answer.
✓ Option (d)
- Since neither statement alone nor both statements together can provide a definitive Yes or No answer, the question cannot be answered even by using both statements together.
- Option (d) is the correct choice.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency requires determining whether the provided statements lead to a unique, unambiguous Yes or No answer.
- The condition p * q > 0 implies p and q share the same algebraic sign (both positive or both negative).
- The condition p^2 > q^2 implies that the absolute magnitude of p is greater than that of q, written as |p| > |q|.
- For positive numbers with same sign, |p| > |q| implies p > q.
- For negative numbers with same sign, |p| > |q| implies p < q because larger absolute values lie further left on the real number line.
- Testing positive and negative cases is essential before concluding sufficiency in inequality problems.
Related facts for revision
- Properties of square inequalities: a^2 > b^2 is equivalent to (a - b)(a + b) > 0 or |a| > |b|.
- Effect of negative multiplier on inequalities: multiplying or dividing by a negative number reverses the inequality direction.
- Testing special values in CSAT Data Sufficiency: positive integers, negative integers, fractions between 0 and 1, and zero.
- Sufficient vs Insufficient criteria: a statement is sufficient only if it gives one consistent answer in all possible valid cases.
How UPSC tests this
Testing edge cases involving positive versus negative real numbers when analyzing quadratic or product inequalities.
Trap: Candidates often assume p and q must be positive numbers when p^2 > q^2 and p * q > 0, leading them to pick option (c) incorrectly.
← Previous · Q55What is the middle term of the sequence Z, Z, Y, Y, Y, X, X, X, X, W, W, W, W,…Next · Q57 →Question: Is (p + q - r) greater than (p - q + r), where p, q and r are…
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
Each item in this section contains a question followed by two statements. Mark (a) if answerable using ONE statement alone but not the other; (b) if either alone suffices; (c) if both together but not either alone; (d) if not…
See the answer & explanation →
For two distinct real numbers x and y, which of them is bigger? I. x² < y < 1 II. y < √x < 1
See the answer & explanation →
If x and y are integers, then is x even? I. x²y² is even. II. 1 + x² + y² is odd.
See the answer & explanation →
X is a collection of certain odd numbers whereas Y is a collection of certain even numbers. T consists of the numbers all of which are either from X or from Y. Is every number of T from Y? I. The sum of any two numbers belonging…
See the answer & explanation →All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.