UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q11 · Comprehension
The emissions humans put into the atmosphere now will affect the climate in the middle of the century and onwards. Technological change, meanwhile, could make a future transition away from fossil fuels cheap or it might not, leaving the world with a terrible choice between sharply reducing emissions at huge cost or suffering through the effects of unabated warming. Businesses that do not hedge against the threat of uncertain outcomes fail. The world cannot afford such recklessness on climate change.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crucial message conveyed by the author of the passage?
- aBusinesses that cause emissions may need to close down or pay for pollution in future.
- bThe only solution is technological development related to the issues of climate change.
- cWaiting to deal with carbon emissions until technology improves is not a wise strategy.
- dSince future technological change is uncertain, new industries should be based on renewable energy sources.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The author highlights that future technological solutions are uncertain, making it reckless to delay carbon emission reductions while waiting for technology to improve.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The author uses the business practice of hedging against risk as an analogy for climate action.
- The passage does not state or imply that emitting businesses must close down or pay for pollution in the future.
- The passage explicitly states that technological change might not make the future transition cheap or viable.
- Categorizing technological development as the only solution contradicts the author's warning against relying on uncertain future tech.
- The passage emphasizes that waiting for uncertain technology leaves the world with a terrible choice between huge costs and unabated warming.
- Comparing such inaction to reckless business practices supports the core message that waiting for technological improvements is not a wise strategy.
- The passage makes no reference to renewable energy sources or how new industries should be structured.
- This option introduces external real-world ideas that fall outside the boundary of the provided text.
Concept to know
- Identify the central thesis by focusing on the overall argument rather than illustrative analogies or minor details.
- Distinguish between main conclusions and supporting examples such as the mention of business risk management.
- Watch out for extreme keywords like only or always, which often signal incorrect options in reading comprehension.
- Eliminate options that introduce external concepts like renewable energy when they are not supported by the passage text.
- Evaluate whether an option captures the risk mitigation message conveyed by the author.
Related facts for revision
- Crucial message questions require identifying the main actionable takeaway intended by the author.
- Inference questions require logical deductions that remain strictly within the bounds of the given passage.
- Assumption questions involve identifying unstated premises necessary for the conclusion to hold true.
- Avoid real-world bias where factually true statements tempt test-takers away from text-based evidence.
Ability to extract the primary message of a passage without falling for external knowledge traps or extreme statements.
Trap: Option (d) is a classic real-world trap where candidates choose renewable energy because it sounds logically correct outside the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.