EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q72 · Comprehension

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ72
SubjectComprehension

"Science by itself is not enough, there must be a force and discipline outside the sciences to coordinate them and point to a goal. It is not possible to run a course aright when the goal itself has not been rightly placed. What science needs is philosophy — the analysis of scientific method and the coordination of scientific purposes and results; without this, any science must be superficial. Government suffers, precisely like science, for lack of philosophy. Philosophy bears to science the same relationship which statesmanship bears to politics : movement guided by total knowledge and perspective, as against aimless and individual seeking. Just as the pursuit of knowledge becomes scholasticism when divorced from the actual needs of men and life, so the pursuit of politics becomes a destructive bedlam when divorced from science and philosophy."

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most rational, logical and practical message conveyed by the passage?

  1. aModern statesmen need to be well trained in scientific methods and philosophical thinking to enable them to have a better perspective of their roles, responsibilities and goals.
  2. bIt is not desirable to have Governments managed by empirical statesmen unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning and reflect wisdom.
  3. cAs the statesmen/bureaucrats are the products of a society, it is desirable to have a system of education in a society that focuses on training its citizens in scientific method and philosophical thinking from a very early age.
  4. dIt is desirable that all scientists need to be philosophers as well to make their work goal-oriented and thus purposeful and useful to the society.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) It is not desirable to have Governments managed by empirical statesmen unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning and reflect wisdom.

The passage highlights that politics divorced from total knowledge, science, and philosophy becomes aimless and destructive, making unguided empirical governance undesirable without the integration of wisdom and learning.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • The passage emphasizes the necessity of philosophical perspective in governance, but it does not prescribe a specific training program for modern statesmen.
  • It over-specifies the solution into a concrete training requirement that is not explicitly advocated by the author.
✓ Option (b)
  • The author argues that aimless and individual seeking leads to destructive governance just as science without philosophy remains superficial.
  • This directly supports the conclusion that empirical governance lacking total knowledge, wisdom, and philosophical perspective is undesirable.
✗ Option (c)
  • The text makes no reference to early childhood education, school curricula, or bureaucrats as social products.
  • This option introduces outside assumptions not grounded in the passage.
✗ Option (d)
  • The passage states that science as a collective field needs philosophy for coordination and direction.
  • It does not claim that every individual scientist must literally become a professional philosopher.

Concept to know

  • Identify the central thesis by analyzing core analogies (philosophy is to science what statesmanship is to politics).
  • Recognize the scope of the passage and avoid options that introduce unstated policy prescriptions or practical mechanisms.
  • Evaluate tone and logical implications to differentiate between extreme mandates and balanced inferences.
  • Eliminate options that rely on external real-world knowledge rather than explicit passage statements.

Related facts for revision

  • Main idea versus extrapolation questions in CSAT reading comprehension.
  • Identifying distractor options containing extreme words like all, always, or mandatory.
  • Analyzing analogical reasoning used by authors to build normative arguments.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to extract the core logical message from an abstract philosophical passage without over-extrapolating.

Trap: Option (a) is a common trap because it sounds pragmatic, but option (b) accurately reflects the author's warning against purely empirical governance devoid of broader wisdom.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.