UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q6 · Numeracy
There are four letters and four envelopes and exactly one letter is to be put in exactly one envelope with the correct address. If the letters are randomly inserted into the envelopes, then consider the following statements:
1. It is possible that exactly one letter goes into an incorrect envelope.
2. There are only six ways in which only two letters can go into the correct envelopes.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement 1 is impossible because misplacing one letter automatically misplaces at least one more letter, while Statement 2 correctly counts C(4, 2) × 1 = 6 ways.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- If exactly one letter goes into a wrong envelope, the envelope intended for that letter must receive another letter.
- This forces at least a second letter to be in an incorrect envelope.
- Therefore, the minimum number of incorrectly placed letters is two, making it impossible for exactly one letter to be misplaced.
- To have exactly two letters in correct envelopes, choose 2 correct letters out of 4 using C(4, 2) = 6 ways.
- The remaining 2 letters must both go into incorrect envelopes, which can happen in only 1 way (derangement D(2) = 1).
- Total ways = C(4, 2) × D(2) = 6 × 1 = 6 ways, so Statement 2 is correct.
- This option claims only Statement 1 is correct, but Statement 1 is logically impossible.
- Statement 1 is false and Statement 2 is true, making option b the correct choice.
- This option claims both statements are correct, but Statement 1 is false.
- This option claims neither statement is correct, but Statement 2 is mathematically correct.
Concept to know
- Derangement formula: The number of ways to arrange n items such that none appear in their original correct position is given by D(n) = n! × (1 - 1/1! + 1/2! - 1/3! + ... + (-1)^n / n!).
- Base derangement values: D(1) = 0, D(2) = 1, D(3) = 2, D(4) = 9.
- Impossible misplacement: Exactly 1 item out of n items can never be misplaced because displacing 1 item forces at least 1 other item out of its correct slot.
- Combination selection: Selecting k items to be placed correctly out of n items uses C(n, k) = n! / (k! × (n - k)!).
- Product rule for compound events: Total ways to have exactly k correctly placed items out of n items is C(n, k) × D(n - k).
Related facts for revision
- Derangements of 4 items: The number of ways to put all 4 letters in wrong envelopes is D(4) = 9.
- Probability of complete derangement: For 4 letters, the probability that all letters go into wrong envelopes is 9 / 24 = 3/8.
- Exactly 3 correct letters out of 4: Impossible because D(4 - 3) = D(1) = 0 ways.
- Total possible permutations: Placing 4 letters into 4 envelopes can be done in 4! = 24 total ways.
Logical reasoning regarding derangements, combinations, and basic counting principles.
Trap: Candidates often assume 1 misplaced letter is possible without realizing that misplacing 1 letter forces at least a second letter to be displaced.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.