EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q35 · Comprehension

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ35
SubjectComprehension

Food consumption patterns have changed substantially in India over the past few decades. This has resulted in the disappearance of many nutritious foods such as millets. While food grain production has increased over five times since independence, it has not sufficiently addressed the issue of malnutrition. For long, the agriculture sector focussed on increasing food production particularly staples, which led to lower production and consumption of indigenous traditional crops/grains, fruits and other vegetables, impacting food and nutrition security in the process. Further, intensive, monoculture agriculture practices can perpetuate the food and nutrition security problem by degrading the quality of land, water and food derived through them.

Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. To implement the Sustainable Development Goals and to achieve zero-hunger goal, monoculture agriculture practices are inevitable even if they do not address malnutrition.
2. Dependence on a few crops has negative consequences for human health and the ecosystem.
3. Government policies regarding food planning need to incorporate nutritional security.
4. For the present monoculture agriculture practices, farmers receive subsidies in various ways and government offers remunerative prices for grains and therefore they do not tend to consider crop diversity.
Which of the above assumptions are valid ?

  1. a1, 2 and 4 only
  2. b2 and 3 only
  3. c3 and 4 only
  4. d1, 2, 3 and 4
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) 2 and 3 only

Statements 2 and 3 logically flow from the passage regarding crop diversity and nutrition security, while Statements 1 and 4 introduce extreme assertions or external real-world facts not supported by the text.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement 1
  • The passage states that intensive monoculture degrades land, water, and food quality, thereby perpetuating malnutrition rather than solving it.
  • Claiming that monoculture is inevitable to achieve zero-hunger contradicts the text and uses an unsupportable extreme word, inevitable.
✓ Statement 2
  • The passage explicitly connects the focus on staple crops with reduced consumption of traditional nutritious grains and vegetables.
  • It also directly notes that intensive monoculture degrades land and water quality, confirming negative impacts on both human health and ecosystems.
✓ Statement 3
  • The passage highlights that past focus on mere food grain quantity failed to address malnutrition and impacted nutrition security.
  • Therefore, the author implicitly assumes that future food planning policies must incorporate nutritional security alongside mere caloric production.
✗ Statement 4
  • While government subsidies and remunerative prices exist in real life, the passage nowhere mentions subsidies or price incentives for farmers.
  • An assumption must be derived strictly from the premises given within the passage, making outside facts invalid as passage-based assumptions.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must believe to be true for their main argument to hold valid.
  • Base all assumption evaluations strictly on the given text, avoiding the trap of applying external real-world knowledge.
  • Watch for extreme qualifiers such as inevitable, only, always, or must, which usually make an assumption invalid unless explicitly justified by the text.
  • Identify the central thesis: increased grain production has failed to solve malnutrition due to monoculture and loss of crop diversity.
  • A valid policy assumption directly addresses the core flaw identified in the passage's argument.

Related facts for revision

  • Assumption versus Inference: An assumption is an unwritten baseline premise needed to build the argument, while an inference is a logical conclusion derived from the stated premises.
  • Assumption versus Corollary: A corollary is a natural consequence or secondary proposition that follows directly from a proven conclusion.
  • Outside Knowledge Trap: CSAT comprehension questions frequently include statements that are factually correct in general knowledge but completely absent from the passage.
How UPSC tests this

Evaluating implicit logical assumptions and filtering out external real-world facts from passage text.

Trap: Selecting option (d) or (c) because Statement 4 is a well-known real-world fact about Indian agriculture, even though it has zero textual basis in the passage.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.