UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q78 · Reasoning
Let P, Q, R, S and T be five statements such that:
I. If P is true, then both Q and S are true.
II. If R and S are true, then T is false.
Which of the following can be concluded ?
1. If T is true, then at least one of P and R must be false.
2. If Q is true, then P is true.
Select the correct answer using the code given below :
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Conclusion 1 is logically valid via contrapositive reasoning, whereas Conclusion 2 commits the fallacy of affirming the consequent.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I (P implies Q and S) means its contrapositive is also true: if S is false, then P must be false.
- Statement II (R and S implies not T) means its contrapositive is also true: if T is true, then R and S cannot both be true, so either R is false or S is false.
- If T is true and S is false, P becomes false; if T is true and S is true, R must be false; thus at least one of P or R must be false, making Conclusion 1 valid while Conclusion 2 is invalid.
- Conclusion 2 claims that if Q is true, then P is true, which is the converse of P implies Q.
- Assuming the truth of a converse statement is a formal logical fallacy known as affirming the consequent.
- Therefore, Conclusion 2 does not logically follow.
- Since Conclusion 2 is invalid, both conclusions cannot be correct.
- Option (c) is ruled out.
- Since Conclusion 1 has been proved to be logically correct, option (d) is incorrect.
Concept to know
- A conditional statement P implies Q is logically equivalent to its contrapositive not Q implies not P.
- The converse of a statement Q implies P is not logically equivalent to P implies Q.
- By De Morgan laws, the negation of R and S is equivalent to not R or not S.
- When given disjunctions like not R or not S, evaluation requires case analysis for both possibilities.
- Chain logic connects contrapositives across multiple conditional premises to derive valid conclusions.
Related facts for revision
- Categorical syllogisms involving all and some premises.
- Truth-teller and liar logic puzzles relying on conditional consistency.
- Formal fallacies such as affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent.
- Negation rules for conjunctions and disjunctions in logic.
Understanding of conditional logic, contrapositives, and case-based deductive reasoning.
Trap: Confusing the converse with a valid implication, leading candidates to falsely accept Conclusion 2 and pick option c.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.