EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q34 · Comprehension

Year2023
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ34
SubjectComprehension

There is a claim that organic farming is inherently safer and healthier. The reality is that because the organic farming industry is still young and not well-regulated in India, farmers and consumers, alike, are not only confused about what products are best for them, but sometimes use products in ways that could harm them as well. For example, since organic fertilizers are difficult to obtain on a large scale in India, farmers often use farmyard manure, which may contain toxic chemicals and heavy metals. Certain plant sprays, such as Datura flower and leaf spray, have an element called atropine. If it is not applied in the right dose, it can act on the nervous system of the consumer. Unfortunately, how much and when to use it are not well-researched or regulated issues.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical, rational and practical message conveyed by the author of the passage ?

  1. aIn India, organic farming should not be promoted as a substitute for conventional farming.
  2. bThere are no safe organic alternatives to chemical fertilizers.
  3. cIn India, farmers need to be guided and helped to make their organic farming sustainable.
  4. dThe aim of organic farming should not be to generate huge profits as there is still no global market for its products.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) In India, farmers need to be guided and helped to make their organic farming sustainable.

The passage highlights that India's organic farming industry suffers from a lack of regulation, research, and awareness, implying the practical necessity of guiding and supporting farmers.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • The passage points out existing regulatory and research gaps in organic farming but does not advocate stopping its promotion as a substitute for conventional farming.
✗ Option (b)
  • The statement claims absolutely that no safe organic alternatives exist, which is an extreme extrapolation unsupported by the passage.
✓ Option (c)
  • The passage notes that farmers are confused and lack clear guidelines on product dosage, research, and regulatory safety.
  • Providing guidance, research, and regulation to farmers directly solves the core problems mentioned, making organic farming safer and sustainable.
✗ Option (d)
  • The passage makes no reference to global market demand, exports, or profit motives behind organic farming.

Concept to know

  • Identify the core problem presented in the passage to determine the author's underlying practical message.
  • Distinguish between balanced, pragmatic recommendations and extreme or absolute statements.
  • Derive logical implications directly from stated challenges like lack of research, improper regulation, and farmer confusion.
  • Avoid incorporating external knowledge or unstated assumptions regarding global trade or conventional agriculture.

Related facts for revision

  • Inference-based reading comprehension questions requiring pragmatic problem-solving extensions.
  • Differentiating between illustrative examples (like Datura spray) and the overarching argument of the text.
  • Identifying extreme qualifier words such as 'no', 'never', or 'completely' to eliminate incorrect options.
  • Strategies for answering 'most logical, rational and practical message' question types in CSAT Paper II.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to analyze contextual problems and infer the most constructive, practical recommendation grounded in text premises.

Trap: Options (a) and (b) use extreme language not supported by the text, which traps candidates who over-extrapolate the author's critique of current organic practices.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.