UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Q44 · Numeracy
A principal P becomes Q in 1 year when compounded half-yearly with R% annual rate of interest. If the same principal P becomes Q in 1 year when compounded annually with S% annual rate of interest, then which one of the following is correct?
- aR = S
- bR > S
- cR < S
- dR ≤ S
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Compounding half-yearly yields extra interest on interest, so a lower nominal rate R is sufficient to match the amount generated by a simple annual compounding rate S, proving R < S.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- If R = S, the half-yearly amount Q1 = P(1 + R/200)^2 = P(1 + R/100 + R^2/40000) would be strictly greater than the annual amount Q2 = P(1 + S/100).
- Equal nominal rates with different compounding frequencies cannot produce equal final amounts.
- If R > S, then R/100 + R^2/40000 would be much greater than S/100.
- This would cause the half-yearly compounded amount to significantly exceed the annually compounded amount Q, contradicting the problem statement.
- Equating the two amounts gives P(1 + R/200)^2 = P(1 + S/100), which expands to 1 + R/100 + R^2/40000 = 1 + S/100.
- Simplifying yields S/100 = R/100 + R^2/40000, and since R^2/40000 is positive for any R > 0, S/100 > R/100, which means R < S.
- Option (d) includes the possibility of equality R = S.
- Since R^2/40000 is strictly positive for non-zero interest rates, equality R = S is mathematically impossible, leaving R < S as the only correct relation.
Concept to know
- The compound interest formula for compounding n times per year at nominal annual rate r is A = P(1 + r/(100n))^(nt).
- Half-yearly compounding for 1 year means rate per period is R/2 percent with 2 time periods, giving Q = P(1 + R/200)^2.
- Annual compounding for 1 year means rate per period is S percent with 1 time period, giving Q = P(1 + S/100).
- Increasing the compounding frequency raises the effective yield for a fixed nominal rate due to interest compounding mid-year.
- To obtain the same final amount Q, the scheme with lower compounding frequency must have a higher nominal interest rate, so S must be strictly greater than R.
Related facts for revision
- Effective Annual Rate (EAR) formula is EAR = (1 + r/n)^n - 1, which measures actual annual interest yield.
- Quarterly compounding for 1 year divides the nominal annual rate by 4 and uses 4 conversion periods.
- For equal nominal rates, continuous compounding yields maximum interest, followed by monthly, quarterly, half-yearly, and annual compounding.
- Algebraic expansion of (1 + R/200)^2 gives 1 + R/100 + R^2/40000, where the term R^2/40000 represents the extra interest earned from half-yearly compounding.
Understanding effective interest rates versus nominal rates and performing algebraic comparison of compound interest expressions.
Trap: Confusing nominal rate with effective yield and assuming that more frequent compounding requires a higher rate R, leading candidates to incorrectly choose R > S.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.