EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q27 · Comprehension

Year2026
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ27
SubjectComprehension

Which of the following reflect the intent of the writer in the above passage?
I. To evolve methodologies for objective analysis of the two viruses
II. To establish the epidemiological similarities and differences between the two viruses
III. To offer a better understanding of the remedies of HMPV when analysed in conjunction with SARS-CoV-2

  1. a1 and 2
  2. b2 and 3
  3. c1 and 3
  4. dNone of the above
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) None of the above

The writer contrasts HMPV and SARS-CoV-2 only to argue that two superficially comparable viruses behave very differently in human populations. None of the three statements captures that purpose.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement 1
  • The passage neither proposes nor sketches any methodology for analysing the viruses.
  • It only contrasts features of the two viruses that are already known.
  • Evolving methodologies is a research-design goal that goes far beyond the writer's scope, so this is an over-ambitious reading.
✗ Statement 2
  • The passage does mention differences, but the writer is not carrying out a systematic epidemiological comparison.
  • The contrast in outcomes, exposure history and seasonality is a vehicle for the larger point about response strategy and novelty-driven pandemics.
  • This statement mistakes the means (a comparison) for the end (the intent), so it overstates the case.
✗ Statement 3
  • The passage does not discuss remedies, treatment or cures for HMPV at all.
  • Its focus is on outcomes, exposure history and seasonality, not therapeutics.
  • This is an extraneous idea brought in from outside the passage, so it is unsupported.

Concept to know

  • Intent or purpose questions ask what the writer is trying to achieve, not merely what topics the passage mentions.
  • First state the central idea of the passage in one sentence. Here it is that two comparable-looking viruses behave very differently in human populations, which matters for how we respond to them.
  • Test each statement on three filters: is it in the passage (support), is it the main aim rather than a supporting device (centrality), and is its scope matched rather than inflated (scope).
  • Words such as evolve methodologies, establish, and offer remedies signal scope inflation. Reject them unless the passage actually does that work.
  • A comparison inside a passage is usually a device to make a point. Do not confuse the device with the purpose.
  • When every statement fails the filters, choose None of the above with confidence. UPSC does use it as the correct answer.

Related facts for revision

  • Main idea or central theme questions use the same skill: pick the option that covers the whole passage, neither too narrow nor too broad.
  • Inference versus assumption questions: an inference must follow from the text, while an assumption is an unstated premise the argument needs. Outside facts are traps in both.
  • Author's tone or attitude questions: judge the writer's stance (cautionary, analytical, critical) from word choice, not from the topic.
  • Science-based passages (viruses, climate, technology) tempt candidates to use domain knowledge. Answer only from the text.
  • Combination options (1 and 2, 2 and 3, and so on): eliminate one clearly wrong statement to strike out several options in one move.
How UPSC tests this

Identifying the author's purpose and separating it from the content or devices used in the passage, along with judging scope.

Trap: Statement 2 tempts candidates because the passage does mention differences between the two viruses, so (a) or (b) looks right. But the comparison is only a tool for the writer's larger point. Time-saver: rule out Statement 3 at once (remedies are never discussed), which eliminates (b) and (c). Then test Statement 2 for centrality, and (d) follows.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.