UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q39 · Comprehension
Which of the following conclusions is/are valid?
I. Only a serious offence as categorised by the revised JJ Act, justifies the transfer of a case to the adult judicial system.
II. The JJ Act, 2021, categorises an offence as a serious offence based on the maximum sentence it carries, rather than on the minimum sentence.
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement II directly aligns with the passage regarding the 2021 amendment categorising serious offences by maximum sentence, while Statement I wrongly substitutes serious offences for heinous offences as the ground for transfer to the adult system.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage specifies that transfer of juveniles aged 16 to 18 to the adult judicial system applies strictly to heinous offences, not serious offences.
- Statement I incorrectly claims that a serious offence justifies transfer to the adult system, misrepresenting the statutory threshold described in the passage.
- The passage explicitly notes that the 2021 Amendment Act resolved legal ambiguity by categorising serious offences based on carrying a maximum punishment, rather than relying on minimum punishment.
- This makes Statement II a direct and valid conclusion directly supported by the text.
Concept to know
- Pay close attention to statutory definitions and categories distinguishing heinous, serious, and petty offences in reading comprehension passages.
- Watch out for term-substitution traps where the passage uses one specific technical term but the statement substitutes another related term.
- Evaluate absolute qualifiers like only carefully against the precise conditions described in the text.
- Verify whether legal parameters such as minimum sentence versus maximum sentence match the passage description accurately.
Related facts for revision
- Distinguishing between necessary and sufficient conditions in passage-based inference questions.
- Handling extreme keywords such as only, always, never, and all in reading comprehension options.
- Tracking comparative metrics in passages, such as minimum threshold vs maximum cap.
- Identifying scope distortion where facts from two different statutory categories are merged into a single statement.
Detail-oriented reading comprehension, precise mapping of legal terminology, and detecting term-substitution traps.
Trap: Candidates often miss the distinction between serious and heinous offences in legal passages, assuming all non-minor offences trigger transfer to adult courts. Always verify exact terms.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.