UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q63 · Comprehension
Which of the following conclusions are correct?
I. In the breakaway phase, economic progress is slow for the technology followers.
II. In the catch-up phase, leaders stagnate and followers, therefore, close the gap between them and the leaders.
III. In the fine-tuning phase, technology is exhausted, as it were, and both leaders and followers attempt to extract leftover benefits, leading to more or less similar per capita income levels.
IV. Industrial technology followed scavenging, which preceded hunting, which itself was followed by farming.
- a3 and 4 only
- b1, 2, 3 and 4
- c1 and 2 only
- d2, 3 and 4 only
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements III and IV accurately reflect the convergence dynamics and historical timeline described in the passage.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- In the breakaway phase, technological leaders race ahead rapidly, widening the income gap between leaders and followers.
- The passage defines this phase by the rapid advancement of leaders rather than absolute slow progress among followers.
- Attributing slow economic progress directly to followers misrepresents the primary mechanism of this phase.
- In the catch-up phase, followers close the gap by adopting and diffusing technologies already developed by leaders.
- The convergence occurs because followers absorb existing technology, not because leaders stagnate.
- The statement incorrectly identifies leader stagnation as the underlying cause for closing the income gap.
- In the fine-tuning phase, technological innovation reaches maturity and potential new gains become exhausted.
- Both leaders and followers extract remaining incremental benefits, resulting in similar per capita income levels.
- This accurately summarizes the mature convergence stage described in the passage.
- The historical progression outlined in the passage moves from scavenging to hunting, then to farming, and finally to industrial technology.
- Scavenging preceded hunting, hunting preceded farming, and farming preceded industrial technology.
- This statement faithfully reproduces the chronological sequence provided in the passage.
Concept to know
- Distinguish explicit cause-and-effect relationships from incorrect premise associations in reading comprehension.
- Track phase-based models by identifying the unique features and mechanisms of each phase.
- Verify chronological sequences directly against the exact historical order stated in the text.
- Watch out for statements that pair a correct overall outcome with an inaccurate explanatory mechanism.
- Use elimination techniques when specific multi-statement options can be ruled out by establishing one statement as false.
Related facts for revision
- Economic convergence and growth models in CSAT reading passages.
- Premise distortion traps where plausible outcomes have incorrect stated causes.
- Chronological sequence verification in aptitude comprehension tests.
- Elimination strategies for multi-statement inference questions.
Analytical reading skills, causal logic verification, and chronological accuracy in reading comprehension.
Trap: Choosing option (b) by assuming all four statements sound plausible without verifying the specific causal mechanisms in statements I and II.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.