EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q33 · Reasoning

Year2026
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ33
SubjectReasoning

P, Q, R, S and T are ranked 1 to 5 (not necessarily in that order). The rank of P is 4, the rank of Q is not 5, the rank of R is 1, the rank of S is not 2, the rank of T is not 3. Then which of the following is/are correct?
I. If the rank of S is 3, then that of T is 2.
II. If the rank of Q is 3, then that of T is 5.

  1. aI only
  2. bII only
  3. cBoth I and II
  4. dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Neither I nor II

With P = 4 and R = 1, the only valid arrangements are (Q2, S3, T5) and (Q3, S5, T2), so T = 5 when S = 3 and T = 2 when Q = 3, which makes both statements false.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Fixed ranks are P = 4 and R = 1, so Q, S and T share the ranks {2, 3, 5}. The bans give Q in {2, 3}, S in {3, 5} and T in {2, 5}.
  • If S = 3, then Q and T share {2, 5}. Q cannot be 5, so Q = 2 and T = 5.
  • Statement I claims T = 2, which is wrong, so 'I only' is ruled out.
✗ Option (b)
  • If Q = 3, then S and T share {2, 5}.
  • S cannot be 2, so S = 5 and T = 2.
  • Statement II claims T = 5, which is wrong, so 'II only' is ruled out.
✗ Option (c)
  • Both statements are false, so they cannot both be correct.
  • The full case list confirms this. If Q = 2, then T must take 5 (because T cannot be 3) and S = 3. If Q = 3, then S = 5 and T = 2.
  • In both cases T's rank is the opposite of what each statement claims.
✓ Option (d)
  • Statement I fails because S = 3 forces T = 5, not 2.
  • Statement II fails because Q = 3 forces T = 2, not 5.
  • Neither statement holds, so the answer is (d).

Concept to know

  • Start by fixing the given positions (P = 4, R = 1) and listing the leftover ranks {2, 3, 5} for the unplaced people.
  • Turn each 'not' condition into an allowed set: Q in {2, 3}, S in {3, 5}, T in {2, 5}. This is a possibility grid.
  • For an 'If X, then Y' statement, assume the 'if' part, remove that rank from the others and propagate until each person has a single value.
  • When a person has only two options left and one is taken, the other is forced. This chain of forcing (elimination) decides the answer.
  • Listing every valid arrangement is quick here: only two exist, (Q2, S3, T5) and (Q3, S5, T2). Any conditional can be checked directly against this list.

Related facts for revision

  • Conditional ranking or seating questions ask 'If A is at position k, who is at position m?'. Always solve inside that assumed scenario only.
  • 'Which must be true' asks what holds in all valid arrangements. 'Which could be true' asks what holds in at least one. Enumerating all cases answers both.
  • Matching problems (persons to ranks, days or colours with 'not' clues) use the same grid method of crossing out banned cells.
  • If the number of valid arrangements is small (two or three), list them all first. This saves time across multiple statements.
  • Watch for statements that swap the true outcome, as here: the real pairings are S3 with T5 and Q3 with T2, while the statements pair S3 with T2 and Q3 with T5.
How UPSC tests this

Logical deduction through elimination in a small ranking problem, and handling conditional (if-then) statements.

Trap: Candidates often pick (a) or (c) because T can be 2 in some arrangement and 5 in another. They then accept a statement without checking that particular conditional case. Time-saver: write the two possible arrangements in 20 seconds and test both statements against them.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.