UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q33 · Reasoning
P, Q, R, S and T are ranked 1 to 5 (not necessarily in that order). The rank of P is 4, the rank of Q is not 5, the rank of R is 1, the rank of S is not 2, the rank of T is not 3. Then which of the following is/are correct?
I. If the rank of S is 3, then that of T is 2.
II. If the rank of Q is 3, then that of T is 5.
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
With P = 4 and R = 1, the only valid arrangements are (Q2, S3, T5) and (Q3, S5, T2), so T = 5 when S = 3 and T = 2 when Q = 3, which makes both statements false.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Fixed ranks are P = 4 and R = 1, so Q, S and T share the ranks {2, 3, 5}. The bans give Q in {2, 3}, S in {3, 5} and T in {2, 5}.
- If S = 3, then Q and T share {2, 5}. Q cannot be 5, so Q = 2 and T = 5.
- Statement I claims T = 2, which is wrong, so 'I only' is ruled out.
- If Q = 3, then S and T share {2, 5}.
- S cannot be 2, so S = 5 and T = 2.
- Statement II claims T = 5, which is wrong, so 'II only' is ruled out.
- Both statements are false, so they cannot both be correct.
- The full case list confirms this. If Q = 2, then T must take 5 (because T cannot be 3) and S = 3. If Q = 3, then S = 5 and T = 2.
- In both cases T's rank is the opposite of what each statement claims.
- Statement I fails because S = 3 forces T = 5, not 2.
- Statement II fails because Q = 3 forces T = 2, not 5.
- Neither statement holds, so the answer is (d).
Concept to know
- Start by fixing the given positions (P = 4, R = 1) and listing the leftover ranks {2, 3, 5} for the unplaced people.
- Turn each 'not' condition into an allowed set: Q in {2, 3}, S in {3, 5}, T in {2, 5}. This is a possibility grid.
- For an 'If X, then Y' statement, assume the 'if' part, remove that rank from the others and propagate until each person has a single value.
- When a person has only two options left and one is taken, the other is forced. This chain of forcing (elimination) decides the answer.
- Listing every valid arrangement is quick here: only two exist, (Q2, S3, T5) and (Q3, S5, T2). Any conditional can be checked directly against this list.
Related facts for revision
- Conditional ranking or seating questions ask 'If A is at position k, who is at position m?'. Always solve inside that assumed scenario only.
- 'Which must be true' asks what holds in all valid arrangements. 'Which could be true' asks what holds in at least one. Enumerating all cases answers both.
- Matching problems (persons to ranks, days or colours with 'not' clues) use the same grid method of crossing out banned cells.
- If the number of valid arrangements is small (two or three), list them all first. This saves time across multiple statements.
- Watch for statements that swap the true outcome, as here: the real pairings are S3 with T5 and Q3 with T2, while the statements pair S3 with T2 and Q3 with T5.
Logical deduction through elimination in a small ranking problem, and handling conditional (if-then) statements.
Trap: Candidates often pick (a) or (c) because T can be 2 in some arrangement and 5 in another. They then accept a statement without checking that particular conditional case. Time-saver: write the two possible arrangements in 20 seconds and test both statements against them.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.