UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q71 · Reasoning
Consider the following three statements, namely S1, S2 and S3. S1: Protecting the environment is an existential exigency for humans, given the impact of environmental degradation on climate change. S2: Scientific consensus has not been achieved with regard to the extent of the contribution of human intervention to climate change. S3: Environmental activism includes climate alarmism and other extremist points of view that often become the focus of climate change deniers. Which of the following relationships based on the statements given above is/are correct?
I. S3 is a counterpoint to S1.
II. S3 is unconnected to S1 and S2.
III. S2 could be the reason for S3.
- a2 and 3 only
- b1, 2 and 3
- c1 and 2 only
- d3 only
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Only relationship III is valid because the uncertainty or lack of full scientific consensus (S2) gives climate-change deniers a opening to spotlight extreme environmental activism (S3).
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Relationship II is incorrect because all three statements are logically and contextually linked around climate change discourse.
- Relationship III is correct, but since Relationship II is false, Option (a) cannot be correct.
- Relationship I is incorrect because observing that activism includes extremist fringes (S3) does not refute the necessity of environmental protection for human survival (S1).
- Relationship II is incorrect as S3 is clearly connected to both S1 and S2.
- Relationship I is incorrect because S3 does not serve as a logical counterpoint or direct contradiction to S1.
- Relationship II is incorrect because there is a direct contextual connection between the three statements.
- Relationship I is false because highlighting alarmism in activism (S3) does not negate the existential threat mentioned in S1.
- Relationship II is false because S1, S2, and S3 share clear contextual continuity.
- Relationship III is true because the lack of complete scientific consensus regarding human contribution (S2) provides the pretext for climate-change deniers to focus on alarmist activism (S3).
Concept to know
- Verbal Reasoning and Logical Deduction evaluate the structural and causal relationships between given statements without assuming external facts.
- A counterpoint must directly contradict, refute, or present an opposing argument to another statement.
- Logical connection implies that statements share thematic continuity, causal links, or contextual relevance.
- A causal relationship requires a plausible mechanism where one statement creates the conditions for the second statement to manifest.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying premises and conclusions in critical reasoning passages.
- Evaluating strengthening and weakening arguments in logical deduction.
- Distinguishing cause-and-effect relationships from mere correlation in CSAT passages.
- Spotting underlying assumptions and valid inferences in opinion-based texts.
Critical evaluation of logical relationships, counter-arguments, and plausible causal linkages between statements.
Trap: Mistaking a critique of extreme activism in S3 as a direct counter-argument to the core necessity of environmental protection stated in S1.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.