UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q17 · Comprehension
Which of the following assumptions is/are valid?
I. Deflation strategies can be used to make manufacturers appear to be doing better than they actually are.
II. When input and output prices are both deflated against a single input price, it is referred to as 'double deflation'.
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage shows that the choice of deflation method can make a manufacturer look more productive than it really is. Statement 2 gets double deflation backwards, because double deflation uses separate deflators for inputs and outputs, not one single price.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The core critique of the passage is that single-deflator accounting can make a manufacturer look as if it is more productive than it actually is.
- If one price index is used for everything, a change in relative prices, such as cheaper inputs, shows up as an apparent gain in real output or productivity.
- Statement 1 widens this to 'deflation strategies' in general. That is a fair reading, since the method chosen affects how well the manufacturer appears to perform.
- The statement says double deflation means deflating both input and output prices against a single input price. This is the opposite of what the term means.
- Under double deflation, output is deflated by an output price index and inputs are deflated by an input price index, so the word 'double' refers to two separate deflators.
- Using one price for both is the single-deflation approach that the passage criticises, so Statement 2 misdefines the term.
Concept to know
- In assumption and validity questions, test each statement against the passage's central argument and against any definitions the passage gives.
- Single deflation means nominal value added (output minus inputs) is divided by one price index, usually the output price index.
- Double deflation means real output equals nominal output divided by the output deflator, real inputs equal nominal inputs divided by the input deflator, and real value added equals real output minus real inputs.
- When input prices fall faster than output prices, single deflation overstates real value added. This is why the passage says it makes producers look more productive.
- A statement can generalise the passage's point and still be valid if the generalisation follows directly from the author's reasoning. A statement that reverses a definition given or implied in the passage is invalid.
- Read definitional statements word by word. Here the phrase 'a single input price' is exactly what contradicts the idea of 'double'.
Related facts for revision
- Definition-reversal traps: UPSC often swaps a key term, as in single vs double or real vs nominal, while keeping the rest of the sentence plausible.
- Inference vs assumption questions: an assumption is an unstated premise the argument needs, while an inference is a conclusion that follows from the passage. Both must be anchored in the text.
- Over-generalisation check: accept a broadened statement only if the passage's logic supports the broader claim, as 'deflation strategies' does here.
- Economics-flavoured passages, such as those on GDP measurement, price indices or productivity, need no outside knowledge. Answer only from what the passage states.
- In two-statement questions, settling one statement first eliminates two options. Here, rejecting Statement 2 leaves only (a) or (d).
Close reading of a technical passage, and the ability to tell the author's critique of a method apart from the correct definition of the method itself.
Trap: Option (c) tempts candidates who see the familiar term 'double deflation' and the word 'deflated' in Statement 2 and accept it without noticing 'single input price'. To save time, check whether 'double' can mean 'one price' in Statement 2. It cannot, so drop (b) and (c), confirm Statement 1 from the passage's main critique, and mark (a).
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.