UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q46 · Comprehension
Which of the following inferences is/are correct?
I. The source of the energy we consume is the key to the battle for cleaner air.
II. Bans are effective where the will is strong and the people are convinced that such bans are for the greater good of society.
III. There is judicial approval for a policy that intervenes fiscally to facilitate benevolent pricing for cleaner fuel.
- a1 and 2
- b2 and 3
- c1 and 3
- d1 only
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements 1 and 3 are directly supported by the passage's arguments on energy sources and court-backed fiscal pricing, whereas Statement 2 introduces external assertions about public conviction not found in the text.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage emphasizes that shifting from polluting energy sources like diesel to cleaner alternatives is central to improving air quality.
- This confirms that the primary energy source consumed plays a decisive role in achieving cleaner air outcomes.
- The passage attributes policy implementation and success to judicial mandates and executive levers rather than public conviction or collective will.
- While the statement sounds socially plausible, it introduces an out-of-scope generalization not justified by the text.
- The passage explicitly refers to court approval for pricing measures and subsidies that make cleaner fuel affordable.
- This directly aligns with the inference that judicial approval exists for fiscal policies facilitating benevolent pricing for clean fuels.
Concept to know
- Inference questions require identifying claims that logically follow from the given text without relying on external real-world assumptions.
- Strictly differentiate between statements that are general truths and those that are derived directly from the passage context.
- Identify core premises such as the linkage between energy source choices and environmental quality metrics.
- Verify whether specific policy mechanisms like fuel subsidies or price controls carry explicit judicial endorsement in the text.
- Eliminate options containing extraneous sociological or moral justifications that the author did not mention.
Related facts for revision
- Assumption questions requiring identification of implicit unstated premises necessary for the passage argument.
- Main Idea questions requiring candidates to synthesize the overarching theme of the text.
- Strengthen or Weaken questions evaluating how new information affects the author conclusions.
- Author Tone and Attitude questions assessing perspective on regulatory and judicial interventions.
Ability to draw precise textual inferences while filtering out plausible but unsupported real-world claims.
Trap: Selecting Statement 2 because public conviction sounds like a logical prerequisite for successful bans, even though the text bases compliance on judicial mandates.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.