UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q79 · Numeracy
There are two chemicals which do not react with each other. A container contains 10 litres of the chemical A. One litre of this chemical is removed from it and one litre of the chemical B is poured. Then one litre of the mixture is removed from the container and one litre of B is poured. If this process of replacing one litre of the mixture by one litre of B is performed once more, then what is the volume of B that is present in the container approximately (in percentage)?
- a25
- b27
- c29
- d31
Show answer & explanationHide answer
After three successive replacements, Chemical A constitutes 72.9 percent of the 10-litre mixture, leaving Chemical B at 27.1 percent, which rounds to approximately 27 percent.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Calculates B as 25 percent, which assumes a linear removal of 1 litre of A in each step without considering dilution.
- Simple subtraction gives 10 minus 3 equals 7 litres of A (30 percent B), but even under incorrect simple removal assumptions, 25 percent does not match.
- Working: 100 percent minus 72.9 percent equals 27.1 percent, not 25 percent.
- Initial volume of Chemical A is 10 litres and total volume remains 10 litres after every step.
- Fraction of Chemical A remaining after each step is (10 - 1) / 10 = 9 / 10.
- After 3 steps, volume of Chemical A = 10 * (9/10)^3 = 10 * 0.729 = 7.29 litres.
- Volume of Chemical B = 10 - 7.29 = 2.71 litres, which is 27.1 percent of the total volume, approximately 27 percent.
- Calculates B as 29 percent, which occurs if one mistakenly counts only two replacement cycles instead of three.
- With 2 replacements, remaining A would be 10 * (0.9)^2 = 8.1 litres, making B equal to 1.9 litres (19 percent), or miscalculating 1 - 0.729 as 0.29.
- Working: 100 - 72.9 = 27.1 percent, which rounds down to 27 percent, not up to 29 percent.
- Calculates B as 31 percent, which overestimates the amount of B added.
- This error happens if a candidate forgets that subsequent replacements remove a mixture containing both A and B, not pure A.
- Working: Correct percentage of B is 27.1 percent, which is closest to option (b).
Concept to know
- The standard formula for repeated dilution of liquid A replaced by liquid B is Final Quantity of A = Initial Quantity of A * (1 - x / V)^n, where V is total volume, x is replaced volume per step, and n is total steps.
- Since the total container volume V remains constant at 10 litres, the percentage of liquid A remaining after n operations is given directly by (1 - x / V)^n * 100 percent.
- The percentage of replacing liquid B present in the final mixture is always equal to 100 percent minus the percentage of liquid A remaining.
- The first operation replaces pure chemical A, while subsequent operations replace a proportional mixture of A and B because the liquids do not react and form a uniform mixture.
- Calculating powers like (0.9)^3 = 0.729 allows quick conversion of fractions to decimals without tedious intermediate calculations.
Related facts for revision
- Varying replacement volume: If different volumes x1, x2, x3 are removed in successive steps, remaining quantity of A = Initial A * (1 - x1/V) * (1 - x2/V) * (1 - x3/V).
- Milk and water replacement problems: The exact same dilution principle applies when milk is repeatedly drawn out and replaced with water.
- Ratio after replacement: If the problem asks for the final ratio of A to B, it can be expressed directly as (Fraction of A left) : (1 - Fraction of A left), here 729 : 271.
- Equal concentration problems: When two containers of different concentrations are mixed repeatedly, weighted averages or alligations can be combined with dilution formulas.
Understanding of successive dilution processes, compound percentage reduction, and ratio-mixture formulas.
Trap: Misinterpreting the phrase performed once more to mean 2 total steps instead of 3, or assuming 1 litre of pure A is removed every time rather than 1 litre of the mixture.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.