UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q55 · Comprehension
Which of the following statements are not correct?
I. The landholdings of Rai Sahib were currently not being used for farming.
II. Temperamentally, Rai Sahib was as greedy as other landlords.
III. It cannot be ascertained that Rai Sahib could have made some money by leasing out the grazing land.
IV. It may be asserted that Rai Sahib valued his tenants and wanted to protect their livelihood.
- a1 and 2 only
- b1 and 3 only
- c3 and 4
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements 1, 2, and 3 are incorrect based on the passage, while statement 4 is correct, making (d) the right choice for statements that are not correct.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage does not state that Rai Sahib's landholdings were lying unused for farming.
- It discusses the reservation of grazing common land, not the agricultural fallow status of his estate.
- Rai Sahib is portrayed as protective and benevolent towards his tenants rather than greedy like typical landlords.
- His decision to forego commercial revenue contradicts the assertion that he was temperamentally as greedy as others.
- The passage implies that leasing out the grazing land would yield financial profit for Rai Sahib.
- Asserting that it cannot be ascertained is false, as the potential economic benefit of leasing common land is an established premise.
- The passage explicitly shows that Rai Sahib valued his tenants and sought to safeguard their livelihood.
- He sacrificed potential personal gain to preserve the grazing resources essential for his tenants.
Concept to know
- CSAT reading comprehension questions with negative stems require identifying statements that directly contradict or lack support in the text.
- Distinguish between explicit statements in the passage and ungrounded external assumptions.
- Pay careful attention to negative qualifiers like 'NOT correct' to avoid selecting true statements by mistake.
- Assess character motivations strictly through the actions and values explicitly described in the passage.
- Avoid importing outside real-world knowledge or making logical leaps beyond the given context.
Related facts for revision
- Elimination strategy of ruling out true statements first when tasked with finding incorrect ones.
- Evaluating 'cannot be ascertained' phrasing when clear contextual evidence is present.
- Identifying contrast markers that differentiate a specific character from general societal norms.
- Handling multi-statement passage questions systematically in paper II.
Ability to identify factual contradictions and process negative question stems accurately.
Trap: Candidates often misread 'NOT correct' as 'correct' and mistakenly choose options containing true statement 4.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.