UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q80 · Decision Making
A shopkeeper employs a delivery boy and gives him a motorcycle for home delivery. For every delivery, the boy is given ₹5. At the end of the day, he also gets ₹2 for every kilometre of the distance covered in the day. The boy wants to earn more than ₹500 a day, but does not want to travel more than 100 km. Which of the following numbers of deliveries would definitely meet his target?
- a80
- b85
- c90
- dThe question cannot be answered due to insufficient data
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The total earnings depend on both the number of deliveries and the total distance travelled, but no relation between deliveries and distance is provided.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- If the boy makes 80 deliveries, his delivery earnings equal 5 × 80 = 400 rupees.
- To exceed 500 rupees, he needs more than 100 rupees from distance, which requires driving more than 50 km.
- If he travels 40 km that day, his total earnings equal 400 + 80 = 480 rupees, failing to reach the target.
- If the boy makes 85 deliveries, his delivery earnings equal 5 × 85 = 425 rupees.
- To exceed 500 rupees, he needs more than 75 rupees from distance, which requires driving more than 37.5 km.
- If he travels 30 km that day, his total earnings equal 425 + 60 = 485 rupees, failing to reach the target.
- If the boy makes 90 deliveries, his delivery earnings equal 5 × 90 = 450 rupees.
- To exceed 500 rupees, he needs more than 50 rupees from distance, which requires driving more than 25 km.
- If he travels only 10 km that day, his total earnings equal 450 + 20 = 470 rupees, failing to reach the target.
- The daily earnings equation is Earnings = 5 × Deliveries + 2 × Distance.
- The problem states distance is at most 100 km, but does not specify any lower bound for distance per delivery or total distance.
- Because the total distance can be very small regardless of the number of deliveries, none of the specific numbers in options (a), (b), or (c) can definitely guarantee earnings above 500 rupees.
Concept to know
- Total earnings in multi-variable linear problems follow the equation Earnings = Rate1 × Quantity1 + Rate2 × Quantity2.
- To check if a target condition is definitely met under constraints, one must evaluate the worst-case scenario with minimum variable values.
- A condition is definitely met only if it holds true for all possible permissible values of independent variables.
- Upper bounds on variables do not determine lower bounds unless a explicit relationship or minimum value is provided.
- Data sufficiency evaluation requires identifying whether all necessary parameters are adequately bounded.
Related facts for revision
- Data sufficiency problems in CSAT test logical completeness rather than mere calculation ability.
- Linear programming and constraint optimization involve evaluating boundary conditions of system inequalities.
- Worst-case analysis requires testing the lowest permissible values of positive variables to verify threshold limits.
- Variable independence traps occur when candidates incorrectly assume a fixed ratio between two separate physical quantities.
Data sufficiency evaluation and logical constraint checking under multi-variable inequality conditions.
Trap: Assuming the delivery boy travels the maximum 100 km every day, leading to the false conclusion that 90 deliveries easily cross 500 rupees.
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.