UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q34 · Reasoning
Two identical straight rods are painted in five distinct colours so that each of them gets divided into five equal parts along the length. In one of them, the portions are marked P1, P2, P3, P4 and P5 (not necessarily in that order) whereas in the other, they are marked Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4 and Q5 (not necessarily in that order). When the rods are kept parallel to each other side by side, P1 and Q3 match, P4 matches Q1 or Q2, and Q4 matches P3 or P5. If Q3 and Q5 are adjacent, which of the following is/are possible?
I. Q3 is marked at the middle portion of the straight rod.
II. P2 is marked at one of the extreme portions of the straight rod.
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
A valid linear arrangement exists where Q3 occupies the middle position (position 3) and P2 occupies an extreme position (position 5) simultaneously while satisfying all given constraints.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I alone is not the complete answer because Statement II can also be satisfied simultaneously.
- By placing Q3 at position 3, P2 can simultaneously be placed at position 5 to satisfy both statements together.
- Statement II alone is not the complete answer because Statement I can also be satisfied simultaneously.
- Selecting II only ignores the fact that a valid layout exists where Q3 is in the middle.
- Consider positions 1 to 5 from left to right along both rods.
- Place Q3 and P1 at position 3, satisfying Statement I and matching condition P1 = Q3.
- Place Q5 at position 2, satisfying the constraint that Q3 and Q5 are adjacent.
- Place Q4 at position 1 and match it with P3, satisfying the condition that Q4 matches P3 or P5.
- Place Q1 at position 4 and match it with P4, satisfying the condition that P4 matches Q1 or Q2.
- Place Q2 at position 5 and P2 at position 5, which satisfies Statement II as P2 is at an extreme end.
- Place P5 at position 2 to complete all 5 positions: Pos 1 (P3, Q4), Pos 2 (P5, Q5), Pos 3 (P1, Q3), Pos 4 (P4, Q1), Pos 5 (P2, Q2).
- This valid configuration proves that both Statement I and Statement II are possible simultaneously.
- Neither I nor II is incorrect because at least one concrete arrangement fulfills all rules and makes both statements true.
Concept to know
- Linear alignment and matching problems involve mapping elements of two parallel sets based on positional constraints.
- The standard technique is to number positions from 1 to N (here 1 to 5) and fill fixed anchor points first.
- Fixed points are conditions given explicitly, such as P1 matching Q3 at the exact same positional index.
- Adjacency constraints restrict an element to indices exactly 1 unit away from a reference position.
- Possibility testing requires constructing at least one valid scenario that does not violate any given rule.
Related facts for revision
- Parallel row seating arrangement problems in logical reasoning.
- Positional mapping with multi-variable constraints.
- Elimination techniques for possibility-based logical statements.
- Trial-and-error grid construction methods for competitive exam aptitude.
Testing logical deduction, systematic case construction, and positional arrangement skills.
Trap: Candidates often assume that proving one statement forces the other to be false; always test if a single configuration can satisfy both statements simultaneously.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.