UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q16 · Comprehension
Which of the following statements is/are correct?
I. Real value should not change in the instance of static output cost and unchanged quantities against falling oil prices.
II. Deflators are to be used separately for inputs and outputs, and this is a practice universally adopted by all economies.
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement 1 misstates the passage's scenario, and Statement 2 is contradicted by the India example, so neither statement is correct.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage's scenario is this: oil (input) prices fall while output prices and output quantities stay unchanged. Under double deflation, real value added should then not change.
- The statement replaces 'output prices' with 'static output cost'. If oil prices fall, the cost of producing output falls, so a static output cost does not match the passage's condition.
- It also speaks of a vague 'real value' instead of real value added. As worded, it is not a faithful restatement of the passage, so it is marked not correct.
- The passage says the same deflator is used for inputs and outputs, 'as in India'.
- So separate deflators (double deflation) are clearly not used by all economies, and India is the counter-example.
- Absolute words like 'universally' and 'all economies' are unsupported by the passage and are falsified by it.
Concept to know
- Value added equals the value of output minus the value of intermediate inputs. Real value added removes the effect of price changes.
- Double deflation deflates output by an output price index and inputs by an input price index, then subtracts. Price-only changes therefore leave real value added unchanged.
- Single deflation uses one deflator for both inputs and outputs. If input prices fall but output prices do not, nominal value added rises and the single deflator shows it as a real gain, falsely suggesting higher productivity.
- Reading strategy: map each statement word by word onto the passage's exact conditions, such as output price versus output cost, and value added versus value.
- Treat absolute qualifiers ('all', 'universally', 'always') as red flags. One counter-example in the passage is enough to reject the statement.
Related facts for revision
- Variants ask which statement the passage 'supports', 'implies' or 'assumes'. Implication questions allow a small logical step, but correctness questions demand a faithful match.
- Example-based negation: when a passage cites a country or case as an exception, any statement claiming universality is automatically wrong.
- Substituted-term trap: UPSC swaps a near-synonym (cost for price, value for value added, growth for level) to create a statement that sounds right but is technically wrong.
- Time-saver: in a two-statement question, eliminate the clearly false statement first. Here, rejecting Statement 2 removes options (b) and (c), leaving only (a) versus (d).
Precise comprehension of an economic mechanism (double versus single deflation), plus the ability to spot overgeneralisation and subtle term substitution.
Trap: Option (a) tempts because Statement 1 seems to echo the passage's line that real value added should not change. The statement, however, alters the condition (output cost instead of output price) and drops 'added'. Reject Statement 2 instantly using the India example, then test Statement 1 strictly against the passage's exact wording.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.