UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q35 · Reasoning
Seven persons A, B, C, D, E, F and G travel by three cars X, Y, Z. A and another two of them travel by X. Only E travels with G. C travels by Z, but B does not travel by Y. Besides, A and B do not travel by the same car. Then which of the following are correct?
I. No one travels alone.
II. Only D travels with F.
III. Only C travels with B.
- aI and II only
- bI and III only
- cII and III only
- dAll the three
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements I and III are logically sound, whereas Statement II is incorrect as both A and D travel with F in Car X.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I is correct, but Statement II is incorrect because Car X contains three persons: A, D, and F.
- Thus, both A and D travel with F, making the word only in Statement II false.
- Statement I is correct because the car sizes are 3, 2, and 2, meaning no person travels alone.
- Statement III is correct because Car Z contains exactly B and C, so only C travels with B.
- Statement II is incorrect because F travels with both A and D in Car X.
- Statement III is correct, but since Statement II is wrong, Option (c) is invalid.
- All three statements cannot be correct because Statement II is false.
- Therefore, Option (d) is eliminated.
Concept to know
- Deductive grouping problems require determining set capacities using total counts and explicit constraints.
- The clue only E travels with G establishes an exclusive two-person group containing solely E and G.
- Since Car X has 3 persons and Car Y has exactly 2 persons, the total of 7 persons forces Car Z to have 2 persons.
- Placing C in Z and ruling out B from Y and X forces B into Z, fully occupying Car Z as {B, C}.
- The remaining unassigned individuals D and F must join A in Car X to complete its 3-person capacity as {A, D, F}.
Related facts for revision
- Grouping and distribution puzzles involving constraints on set sizes and exclusions.
- Exclusive relationship conditions where only person X is paired with person Y.
- Elimination techniques based on car capacity and non-cohabitation constraints.
- Matrix arrangement methods for multi-variable categorical distribution.
Systematic logical deduction, constraint satisfaction, and strict interpretation of restrictive terms like only.
Trap: Misinterpreting only E travels with G as meaning E travels in a car with G plus others, or overlooking that A and D both share Car X with F.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.