UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q36 · Reasoning
There are four statements X, Y, Z and W. Their relations are as follows: If X is incorrect, then so is Z; if Y is incorrect, then W is correct; if W is correct, then X is incorrect. Which of the following is/are correct?
I. If X is correct, then so is Y.
II. If Z is correct, then it is not necessary that Y is correct.
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement I is logically valid because X being correct forces Y to be correct, whereas Statement II is false because Z being correct also strictly guarantees that Y is correct.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I is true: X being correct implies W is incorrect by contrapositive of rule 3, which implies Y is correct by contrapositive of rule 2.
- Statement II is false: Z being correct implies X is correct by contrapositive of rule 1, which in turn forces Y to be correct, making Y necessarily correct.
- Statement II is logically false, as Z being correct strictly forces Y to be correct.
- Both statements cannot be correct because Statement II makes a false claim about Y not being necessarily correct.
- Neither is incorrect because Statement I is demonstrably correct through valid logical steps.
Concept to know
- Conditional logic statements take the standard logical form of If P then Q.
- The contrapositive of If P then Q is If not Q then not P, which always has the exact same truth value as the original statement.
- The inverse (If not P then not Q) and converse (If Q then P) are logical fallacies and do not automatically hold true.
- The hypothetical syllogism or chain rule states that if P implies Q and Q implies R, then P directly implies R.
- To solve complex reasoning statements, represent propositions symbolically and derive all contrapositives before evaluating options.
Related facts for revision
- Syllogisms using terms like All, Some, and No follow similar deductive inference rules.
- Disjunctive statements of the form Either A or B can be rewritten conditionally as If not A then B.
- Common CSAT traps include confusing a statement's converse with its valid contrapositive.
- Drawing directional truth arrows helps trace multi-step implications efficiently in CSAT Paper II.
Logical deduction using conditional statements, contrapositive rules, and transitive chains of implication.
Trap: Assuming that If X is incorrect then Z is incorrect provides no information about Z being correct, thereby missing its contrapositive that Z being correct forces X to be correct.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.