UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q21 · Numeracy
For 1/3 < x < y < 2, which of the following statements is/are always correct?
I. x + 1/x < y + 1/y
II. √(1+y²)/y < √(1+x²)/x
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
√(1+t²)/t = √(1 + 1/t²) strictly decreases for every t > 0, so II always holds. t + 1/t falls on (1/3, 1), so I fails, for example at x = 0.5 and y = 0.8.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Option (a) needs Statement I to be always true and Statement II to fail. Both conditions are wrong.
- Test I with x = 0.5 and y = 0.8. Then x + 1/x = 0.5 + 2 = 2.5 and y + 1/y = 0.8 + 1.25 = 2.05.
- Since 2.5 > 2.05, the claim x + 1/x < y + 1/y is false here, so I is not always correct.
- Rewrite II: √(1+t²)/t = √((1+t²)/t²) = √(1/t² + 1), which is valid because t > 0.
- As t increases, 1/t² decreases, so √(1/t² + 1) decreases. Therefore y > x gives √(1+y²)/y < √(1+x²)/x for every allowed pair.
- Numerical check with x = 0.5 and y = 0.8: √1.25/0.5 = 1.118/0.5 = 2.236 and √1.64/0.8 = 1.281/0.8 = 1.601. Since 1.601 < 2.236, II holds while I fails, so the answer is II only.
- Option (c) needs both statements to be always true.
- Statement I fails for x = 0.5 and y = 0.8 (2.5 > 2.05). It also fails for x = 0.4 and y = 1.5, where 0.4 + 2.5 = 2.9 exceeds 1.5 + 0.667 = 2.167.
- A single counterexample is enough to rule out the words always correct.
- Option (d) needs both statements to fail.
- Statement II is true for all positive x < y, because √(1 + 1/t²) is strictly decreasing for t > 0.
- Statement II therefore holds throughout 1/3 < x < y < 2, and option (d) is ruled out.
Concept to know
- The phrase always correct means the inequality must hold for every pair in the range. One counterexample disproves it, but proving it needs a general argument such as monotonicity.
- If a function f is strictly increasing on an interval, then x < y implies f(x) < f(y). If f is strictly decreasing, then x < y implies f(x) > f(y).
- f(t) = t + 1/t has its minimum value 2 at t = 1, since t + 1/t ≥ 2 by AM-GM. It decreases on (0, 1) and increases on (1, ∞). An interval that contains 1, such as (1/3, 2), therefore gives no fixed order.
- Simplify before testing. √(1+t²)/t becomes √(1 + 1/t²) for t > 0, and the monotonic behaviour is then obvious.
- Choose counterexamples deliberately. When the turning point (here t = 1) lies inside the range, pick both values on the side where the function decreases, for example 0.5 and 0.8.
Related facts for revision
- Variation: if the range were 1 < x < y < 2, Statement I would always be true, because t + 1/t increases for t > 1. Always check whether the turning point lies inside the given interval.
- Similar forms: t − 1/t is increasing for all t > 0, and 1/t decreases for t > 0. Recognising these behaviours lets you settle such statements without calculation.
- Comparing a/b with c/d, or square roots of expressions: squaring is allowed when both sides are positive. For example, comparing √(1+t²)/t reduces to comparing 1 + 1/t².
- AM-GM shortcut: for positive a and b, (a + b)/2 ≥ √(ab), with equality when a = b. This is why t + 1/t ≥ 2, with equality at t = 1.
- In statement-based quant questions, test the boundary values and the turning point first. For t + 1/t, use t = 1/3 (value 10/3), t = 1 (value 2) and t = 2 (value 2.5).
The question tests whether you can judge if an algebraic inequality holds for every value in a range. It needs knowledge of monotonic (increasing or decreasing) functions and the habit of hunting for counterexamples.
Trap: Many candidates pick (c) because they assume a bigger number always gives a bigger t + 1/t. That is true only for t > 1, not on (1/3, 1). Time-saver: try two values below 1 (0.5 and 0.8) to kill I instantly, then rewrite II as √(1 + 1/t²) to see that it decreases. The whole question takes under a minute.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.