UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q47 · Numeracy
A shop owner offers the following discount options on an article to a customer :
1. Successive discounts of 10% and 20%, and then pay a service tax of 10%
2. Successive discounts of 20% and 10%, and then pay a service tax of 10%
3. Pay a service tax of 10% first, then successive discounts of 20% and 10%
Which one of the following is correct?
- a1 only is the best option for the customer.
- b2 only is the best option for the customer.
- c3 only is the best option for the customer.
- dAll the options are equally good for the customer.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
All three options yield the exact same final payable amount due to the commutative property of multiplication.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Incorrect because Option 1 results in a final price equal to 100 × 0.90 × 0.80 × 1.10 = 79.2% of the marked price.
- This option is not better than the others since all three options lead to the exact same final price.
- Incorrect because Option 2 results in a final price equal to 100 × 0.80 × 0.90 × 1.10 = 79.2% of the marked price.
- Reversing the sequence of 10% and 20% discounts yields the same result as Option 1.
- Incorrect because Option 3 results in a final price equal to 100 × 1.10 × 0.80 × 0.90 = 79.2% of the marked price.
- Levying the service tax first before giving discounts yields the exact same final multiplier as levying tax at the end.
- Correct because all three options multiply the initial price by factors of 0.90, 0.80, and 1.10 in different orders.
- Since multiplication is commutative where a × b × c = b × a × c = c × b × a, the final price paid by the customer is identical in all cases.
Concept to know
- Multiplicative factors for percentage change: A discount of d% corresponds to multiplying by (1 - d/100), while a tax of t% corresponds to multiplying by (1 + t/100).
- Commutative property of multiplication: The order of applying successive percentage changes does not alter the final net value because a × b × c = c × a × b.
- Calculating final price: Assuming marked price is 100, final price for Option 1 is 100 × 0.90 × 0.80 × 1.10 = 79.2.
- Effective single discount formula: For successive discounts d1 and d2, net discount percentage is d1 + d2 - (d1 × d2)/100.
- Order independence of tax and discount: Applying tax before or after percentage discounts changes intermediate values but leaves the final overall payable amount unchanged.
Related facts for revision
- Single equivalent discount calculation: Successive discounts of 10% and 20% equal a single discount of 10 + 20 - (10 × 20)/100 = 28%.
- Net percentage change rule: Two consecutive percentage changes x% and y% result in a net change of x + y + (x × y)/100.
- Price markup and discount symmetry: Increasing a price by x% and then discounting by x% results in a net loss of (x/10)^2 percent relative to the original price.
- Direct multiplier method: Using decimal multipliers like 0.9 and 1.1 directly speeds up CSAT calculation compared to traditional step-by-step unitary method.
Understanding of multiplicative factors in successive percentage changes and the commutative property of multiplication.
Trap: Candidates often intuitively assume that paying tax first on a larger base amount makes Option 3 worse. Recognising that percentage changes are continuous multipliers avoids unnecessary calculations and saves time.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.