EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q44 · Comprehension

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ44
SubjectComprehension

In India, authorities always look to store the maximum amount of water in reservoirs during the monsoon season, which is then used for irrigation and generation of electricity during the summer months. It is an internationally accepted practice that the water level of a reservoir should be kept below a certain level before the onset of monsoon season. This is so that when monsoon rains come, there is space to store the excess rainwater and also so that water can be released in a regulated manner. But the authorities store the maximum amount of water in reservoirs even before the close of the monsoon, only to ensure greater electricity generation and irrigation.

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. High risks involved in holding maximum water in reservoirs are due to our over-dependence on hydropower projects.
2. Storage capacity of dams should not be fully used before or during monsoon season.
3. Role of dams in flood control is underestimated in India.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?

  1. a1 and 2 only
  2. b2 only
  3. c3 only
  4. d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) 1, 2 and 3

All three assumptions logically underpin the author's critique of Indian reservoir management practices prioritizing power and irrigation over flood safety.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Statement 1
  • The passage notes that authorities risk storing maximum water early specifically to ensure greater electricity generation and irrigation.
  • This reflects an underlying assumption that high risks are taken because of an over-dependence on hydropower generation and irrigation demands.
✓ Statement 2
  • The passage explicitly states international practice requires keeping water levels below a certain threshold before monsoon onset to leave space for excess rain.
  • Thus, fully utilizing storage capacity before or during the monsoon contradicts safety norms and is assumed to be an unsafe practice.
✓ Statement 3
  • Authorities prioritize power and irrigation over flood control mechanisms like regulated water release and buffer storage.
  • This behavior assumes that the vital role dams play in flood moderation and disaster mitigation is underestimated in Indian operational planning.

Concept to know

  • Assumption identification requires finding unstated premises that must be true for the author's argument or the observed behavior to hold valid.
  • Evaluate whether each assumption directly links the cause (prioritizing power and irrigation) to the effect (ignoring safety guidelines).
  • Differentiate between explicit passage facts and implicit assumptions that motivate the actions of decision-makers described in the text.
  • Check if removing an assumption causes the core rationale behind the decision-makers' actions to collapse.

Related facts for revision

  • Inference vs Assumption questions in CSAT reading comprehension.
  • Identifying logical fallacies such as overgeneralization or false dilemma in passage options.
  • Evaluating author's tone and primary purpose in policy-focused passages.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to identify underlying implicit premises and rationale behind policy actions mentioned in the passage.

Trap: Candidates often reject Statement 1 or Statement 3 thinking terms like 'over-dependence' or 'underestimated' are too strong, but here they explain why authorities take high risks despite international safety norms.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.