EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q27 · Comprehension

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ27
SubjectComprehension

In India, agriculture still engages about half of its workforce, and about 85 per cent of its farms are small and marginal. Compared to China and Vietnam, which have experienced fast structural and rural transformation, India's story is of slow transformation. As a result, poverty reduction in India was at a much slower pace during 1988-2014, compared to China and Vietnam. India's poverty reduction was slow during 1988-2005, but during 2005-2012, it accelerated dramatically—almost three times faster than during the earlier period. What did India do during this period? Research reveals that the relative price scenario changed significantly (by more than 50%) in favour of agriculture in the wake of rising global prices. This boosted private investments in agriculture by more than 50%. As a result, agri-GDP growth touched 4.1% during 2007-2012 as against 2.4% during 2002-2007. The net surplus of agri-trade touched $25 billion in 2013-2014; real farm wages rose by 7% per annum. All this led to unprecedented fall in poverty.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the critical message of the passage?

  1. aIndia should create large-scale off-farm rural employment to reduce poverty in the near future.
  2. bIndia should create a large number of farmer producer companies.
  3. cPrivate investment in agriculture should be given priority over public investment.
  4. dInclusive agricultural growth is key to reduce poverty in the near future.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Inclusive agricultural growth is key to reduce poverty in the near future.

The passage demonstrates that dynamic agricultural growth benefiting small and marginal farmers, through higher real wages and agri-GDP growth, is the primary driver of poverty reduction in India.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Incorrect because off-farm rural employment is not mentioned or advocated in the passage as the main solution for India.
  • While structural transformation in China and Vietnam is noted, the core narrative emphasizes that India achieved rapid poverty reduction between 2005 and 2012 specifically through agricultural growth and rising farm wages.
✗ Option (b)
  • Incorrect because farmer producer companies are nowhere mentioned or implied in the passage.
  • Introducing an unmentioned institutional model is a classic out-of-scope distractor trap in CSAT comprehension.
✗ Option (c)
  • Incorrect because the passage does not compare private investment with public investment nor advocate prioritizing one over the other.
  • The text simply states that favorable price scenarios boosted private investment by more than 50%, without offering a comparative policy mandate against public investment.
✓ Option (d)
  • Correct because the passage highlights that 85% of Indian farms are small and marginal, engaging half the workforce.
  • It presents empirical evidence showing that when agri-GDP grew to 4.1% and real farm wages rose by 7% per year, poverty declined at an unprecedented pace, directly confirming that inclusive agricultural growth is key to poverty reduction.

Concept to know

  • Critical Message Identification: Identify the primary thesis that connects the starting problem statement with the final empirical evidence provided by the author.
  • Strict Passage Reliance: Base choices purely on explicit claims in the text rather than applying outside general knowledge or external policy ideas.
  • Eliminating Out-of-Scope Options: Reject choices introducing terms or models not discussed in the text, such as farmer producer companies or off-farm employment.
  • Avoiding Extreme Comparisons: Discard options that introduce comparative priorities (such as private versus public investment) when the text only mentions one element without comparison.
  • Connecting Premise and Conclusion: Link the premise (85% small and marginal farmers) with the outcome (rapid farm wage growth leading to poverty reduction) to arrive at inclusive agricultural growth.

Related facts for revision

  • Critical Message versus Inference: Critical message summarizes the central argument intended by the author, whereas inference derives an unstated logical consequence.
  • Distractor Pattern - External General Knowledge: CSAT frequently uses real-world correct facts that are absent from the passage to test candidate adherence to given text.
  • Distractor Pattern - Unauthorized Prioritization: Choices that claim one factor must be prioritized over another without text support are consistently incorrect.
  • Scope Verification Strategy: Match key qualifiers in options against the text's facts to ensure no overgeneralization has occurred.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to filter out external knowledge and identify the central message supported by textual evidence.

Trap: Candidates often choose option (a) or (c) because off-farm employment and private investment are prominent economic topics, but option (d) is the only synthesis directly anchored in the author's argument regarding small farmers and farm wages.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.