EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q68 · Numeracy

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ68
SubjectNumeracy

A bottle contains 20 litres of liquid A. 4 litres of liquid A is taken out of it and replaced by same quantity of liquid B. Again 4 litres of the mixture is taken out and replaced by same quantity of liquid B. What is the ratio of quantity of liquid A to that of liquid B in the final mixture?

  1. a4 : 1
  2. b5 : 1
  3. c16 : 9
  4. d17 : 8
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) 16 : 9

After two successive replacements of 4 litres each from a 20-litre container, 16 parts out of 25 parts remain as liquid A and the remaining 9 parts become liquid B, yielding a ratio of 16 : 9.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • This option gives the ratio 4 : 1, which represents the state after only the first replacement where 16 litres of A and 4 litres of B remain (16 : 4 = 4 : 1).
  • It fails to account for the second 4-litre removal and replacement operation.
✗ Option (b)
  • This option represents the ratio of total initial volume to the withdrawn quantity (20 : 4 = 5 : 1).
  • It is a distractor that does not reflect the final ratio of the two liquids in the mixture.
✓ Option (c)
  • Fraction of liquid A remaining after 1 operation = (20 - 4) / 20 = 4/5.
  • Fraction of liquid A remaining after 2 operations = (4/5) × (4/5) = 16/25.
  • This means Liquid A is 16 parts out of 25 total parts, leaving 25 - 16 = 9 parts for Liquid B, giving a ratio of 16 : 9.
✗ Option (d)
  • This option results from incorrect arithmetic or assuming simple linear subtraction instead of geometric concentration decay.
  • Calculating actual volumes gives Liquid A = 12.8 litres and Liquid B = 7.2 litres, which simplifies strictly to 16 : 9 and not 17 : 8.

Concept to know

  • Formula for repeated replacement: Final Amount of Original Liquid = Initial Amount × (1 - x / V)^n, where V is total capacity, x is volume replaced, and n is number of operations.
  • The total volume of the mixture remains constant (20 litres) throughout the process because every withdrawal is matched by an equal refill.
  • Each operation reduces the concentration of the original liquid by a factor of (1 - x / V).
  • The final quantity of Liquid B is calculated by subtracting the remaining quantity of Liquid A from the total container volume.
  • Shortcut method: If the remaining fraction of original liquid is a / b, then the ratio of Original Liquid to New Liquid is a : (b - a).

Related facts for revision

  • Problems involving unequal withdrawal quantities where remaining fraction is computed as (1 - x1/V) × (1 - x2/V).
  • Alligation rule used for mixing two separate mixtures of known concentrations to achieve a desired ratio.
  • Compound interest and depreciation problems, which share the same geometric decay mathematical structure.
How UPSC tests this

Understanding and application of successive replacement formulas and fraction-based shortcuts in quantitative aptitude.

Trap: Confusing the ratio of Liquid A to Total Mixture (16 : 25) with the ratio of Liquid A to Liquid B (16 : 9), or stopping after the first step (4 : 1).

More Numeracy PYQs

All Numeracy questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.