EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q8 · Numeracy

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ8
SubjectNumeracy

Let XYZ be a three-digit number, where (X+Y+Z) is not a multiple of 3. Then (XYZ + YZX + ZXY) is not divisible by

  1. a3
  2. b9
  3. c37
  4. d(X+Y+Z)
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) 9

The sum simplifies to 111(X + Y + Z) or 3 x 37 x (X + Y + Z), which contains only one factor of 3 because (X + Y + Z) is not a multiple of 3, making it impossible to be divisible by 9.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Expressing the numbers in standard positional form gives XYZ = 100X + 10Y + Z, YZX = 100Y + 10Z + X, and ZXY = 100Z + 10X + Y.
  • Summing all three terms yields 111X + 111Y + 111Z = 111(X + Y + Z) = 3 x 37 x (X + Y + Z).
  • Since 3 is a prime factor of 111, the sum is always divisible by 3.
✓ Option (b)
  • For the product 3 x 37 x (X + Y + Z) to be divisible by 9, it must contain at least two factors of 3.
  • The coefficient 111 provides only a single factor of 3.
  • Since the question specifies that (X + Y + Z) is not a multiple of 3, no second factor of 3 is present, so the sum cannot be divisible by 9.
✗ Option (c)
  • The prime factorization of 111 is 3 x 37.
  • Since 37 is an explicit factor of 111, the total sum 111(X + Y + Z) is always divisible by 37.
✗ Option (d)
  • The sum simplifies algebraically to 111 multiplied by (X + Y + Z).
  • Any expression of the form K x N is strictly divisible by N.
  • Thus, the total sum is always divisible by (X + Y + Z).

Concept to know

  • Positional notation represents a three-digit number XYZ as 100X + 10Y + Z.
  • Cyclic permutation sums of three-digit numbers XYZ + YZX + ZXY simplify to 111(X + Y + Z).
  • Prime factorization breaks down 111 into 3 x 37.
  • Divisibility by a composite number such as 9 requires the total prime factorization of the expression to contain 3 x 3.
  • If (X + Y + Z) does not contribute a factor of 3, the total expression contains only one factor of 3, failing divisibility by 9.

Related facts for revision

  • Sum of a 2-digit number and its reverse XY + YX equals 11(X + Y), which is always divisible by 11 and (X + Y).
  • Difference of a 2-digit number and its reverse XY - YX equals 9(X - Y), which is always divisible by 9 and (X - Y).
  • Difference of a 3-digit number and its reverse XYZ - ZXY equals 99(X - Z), which is always divisible by 9, 11, 33, 99, and (X - Z).
  • Plugging in specific values such as X=1, Y=1, Z=2 where sum=4 (not a multiple of 3) gives 112 + 121 + 211 = 444, which is divisible by 3, 37, and 4, but not by 9.
How UPSC tests this

Algebraic expansion of multi-digit numbers using place values and checking divisibility via prime factorization.

Trap: Candidates often ignore the constraint that (X + Y + Z) is not a multiple of 3 and assume 9 could divide the sum, or they miscalculate 111 as a prime number.

More Numeracy PYQs

All Numeracy questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.