UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q64 · Comprehension
Genome editing is different from genome modification. Genome editing typically involves finding the part of a plant genome that could be changed to render it less vulnerable to disease, or resistant to certain herbicides, or to increase yields. Researchers use 'molecular scissors' to dissect the genome and repair it, which is a process that occurs naturally when plants are under attack from diseases and can throw up new mutations that enable the plant to survive future attacks. This evolutionary process can effectively be speeded up now that it is possible to examine plant genomes in detail in laboratories, and create mechanisms through which the relevant genes can be altered very precisely.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Genome editing does not require the transfer of genes from one plant to another.
2. Through genome editing, the chosen genes can be altered precisely in a manner akin to the natural process that helps plants to adapt to the environmental factors.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Both statements logically follow as valid underlying assumptions based on the text's explanation of internal gene editing and its similarity to natural evolutionary mechanisms.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage distinguishes genome editing from general modification by showing that editing works by dissecting, altering, and repairing a plant's existing genome internally using molecular scissors.
- Since the process focuses on altering existing genes within the plant's own genome rather than inserting foreign DNA, it assumes that gene transfer between plants is not required.
- The passage explicitly compares laboratory genome editing to a natural evolutionary process that occurs when plants respond to disease attacks and adapt to environmental threats.
- It highlights that modern techniques allow researchers to precisely alter specific genes to speed up this naturally occurring adaptive repair mechanism.
Concept to know
- Identifying Underlying Assumptions: An assumption is an unstated prerequisite premise that the author must believe to be true for the argument or claim to hold logically valid.
- Distinguishing Internal vs Foreign Processes: Pay close attention to definitions provided in the text; if an internal repair mechanism is described, external addition of materials is not assumed.
- Analogy and Equivalence Mapping: Notice explicit comparisons in the text, such as equating laboratory gene alteration with natural mutation processes triggered by environmental stressors.
- Eliminating Extraneous Information: Ensure that claims do not introduce outside technical knowledge about GMOs unless directly supported by the implicit premise of the passage.
Related facts for revision
- Distinguishing Assumption questions from Inference or Main Idea questions in CSAT Paper II.
- Recognizing tone and scope constraints when passages contrast scientific concepts like editing versus modification.
- Handling double statement validity questions by evaluating each premise independently before looking at combined options.
Evaluating logical assumptions and implicit premises in scientific reading comprehension passages.
Trap: Relying on external biology knowledge regarding Genetically Modified crops rather than strictly identifying what premise the author assumes within the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.